Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Annie Dookhan Story: Examining Hard Power/Soft Power Dynamics in American “Crime Labs”

Wed, Nov 14, 12:30 to 1:50pm, Marriott, M304, Marquis Level

Abstract

The purpose of this paper is to examine the Annie Dookhan story to better educate students of forensic science and criminology on ethical dilemmas that are found within the “crime lab” work setting. Our paper posits that the Annie Dookhan story should be used as a pedagogical device to assist students to better understand the dynamics of hard power and soft power. Scientists are often confronted with the hard power/soft power dichotomy while working for criminal justice agencies. More specifically, this paper encourages students to identify two different types of power that can be found within the “crime lab” workplace, Soft Co-Optive Power and Hard Command Power. Our paper does not position Annie Dookhan as a scapegoat, but rather argues that Annie Dookhan is a highly visible example that should be used to teach students of forensic science and criminology about a common workplace dynamic that is present in the majority of all “crime labs” in America.

Authors