Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Can a Prosecutor Really Indict a Ham Sandwich? Testing Strength of Evidence with Experimental Method

Fri, Nov 18, 3:30 to 4:50pm, International 2, International Level

Abstract

In the USA, prosecutors initiate criminal charges when a grand jury, composed of several members of the public, agrees to indict. Criticisms of the grand jury system are that: 1) prosecutors dominate the process by emphasizing guilt even in weak cases, 2) grand jurors do not take account of defenses, and 3) secrecy masks mistakes and disparities. This study tests these assertions empirically by simulating the grand jury experience. To test whether indictments are based on the weight of evidence presented, over 200 participants served as grand jurors in a burglary case with five types of evidence, each varied as to strong/weak. The hypothesis is that grand jurors will indict when the amount of evidence exceeds 50 – 60%, i.e. that there is probable cause to say the suspect committed the crime. Simulated “grand juries” viewed videos depicting varied strength of evidence and then “deliberated” on whether to indict. Indictments from the experimentally varied amounts and types of evidence showed that grand jurors take the probable cause standard seriously and will not indict a “ham sandwich.” But they will indict in cases with only a bit more evidence and especially with strong evidentiary types such as pawn shop records or clear fingerprints.

Authors