Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

What is a neighborhood? A review of criminological literature, 2010-2020

Fri, Nov 17, 9:30 to 10:50am, Franklin Hall 8, 4th Floor

Abstract

Since pioneering work by the Chicago School, the neighborhood has been a fundamental unit of analysis for criminology. Yet, many object to the vagueness of the concept. What does the concept mean, and does it mean the same thing to different criminologists? No one has tried to answer this question systematically. No one has studied whether criminologists have a definition of neighborhoods that permits scientific inquiry. So we undertook such a study. We searched for all articles that included the term neighborhood in the top 10 journals in criminology: 2010 to 2020. Our search found 2,517 articles mentioning neighborhoods. Of the studies that used neighborhoods as its unit of analysis, few define the term. There was also wide variation in how researchers operationalize the term. Examples include census tracts, census blocks, neighborhood clusters, block groups, dissemination areas, zip codes, counties, grid cells, city districts, school catchment areas, and proactive focus areas. Our conclusion is that criminologists may think they share the same idea of a neighborhood, but they probably do not. If our conclusion is valid, criminologists need to develop a consistent definition to scientifically examine crime in neighborhoods.

Authors