Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How much change is change enough? Examining gender transition in the context discretionary parole release

Fri, Nov 17, 8:00 to 9:20am, Franklin Hall 11, 4th Floor

Abstract

An enduring question in contemporary studies of discretionary parole release is how parole board commissioners with relatively unfettered discretion make decisions about parole suitability, often in the face of either contradictory information about their future risk of recidivism, or no such information at all. A question that looms large in this setting is how an offender can demonstrate meaningful change and transformation in a brief, contrived setting. But what is this process like when the prospective parolee’s transition is literal? In this initial exploratory analysis, I examine a small sample of parole board hearing transcripts involving transgender applicants with a small subset of cisgender applicant parole board hearing transcripts, both from California. How does the Board of Parole Hearings manage and understand questions of gender and change? How do trans applicants fare compared to their cisgender counterparts? How does literal transition in the form of a new gender identity figure in to evaluations of the re-constituted identities of rehabilitated offenders? A small matched sample, subjected to analytic induction, will be used to render initial findings on these themes and foreground future research on gender identity and parole board decision making.

Authors