Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Meltdown: The Martha Mitchell Effect and Nuclear Cinema

Sat, April 13, 1:15 to 2:45pm, Hyatt Regency Columbus, Union D

Abstract

In the opening sequence of The China Syndrome (1979), television reporter Kimberly Wells, played by Jane Fonda, asks a simple question as she waves into the camera: “Hey, fellas, is anybody listening to me?” Her plea captures one of the film’s central themes. The China Syndrome explores the potentially devastating consequences of nuclear power, depicted in the film as an energy system designed to limit citizen interaction and transparency. While atomic energy has typically served as B-movie fodder, this paper examines two critically acclaimed nuclear films, The China Syndrome and Silkwood (1983), which offer subtle, yet sharp representations of the nation’s nuclear complex—at the very moment when those criticisms peaked in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

Even as the filmmakers resist polemical interpretations, both films portray a nuclear industry crippled by greed and financial pressures, but more importantly, by an organizational culture that limited rational responses to serious technical issues. As others dismiss the whistleblowers’ claims, and question their sanity, each film employs a version of the “Martha Mitchell effect,” where real concerns are dismissed as delusions. By challenging the nuclear industry’s organizational culture and profit motives, and searching for a clear resolution with inherently risky and complex technologies, whistleblowers are driven to emotional despair, as in Silkwood, or to quite literal meltdowns in order to prevent a nuclear one in The China Syndrome. Navigating the murky territory of delusion versus reality, these films deftly render the minefield, and inescapable ambiguity, of 1970s energy politics on screen.

Author