Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Comparison of Refugee-Background Student Support in New Zealand and the United States: Imagining a Better Future

Mon, March 9, 8:00 to 9:30am, Washington Hilton, Floor: Concourse Level, Georgetown West

Abstract

Purpose:

The purpose of this study was to compare United States and New Zealand policy and practice with regards to refugee-background students. Both countries have resettled refugees since World War II. Two years ago, NZ endorsed a new resettlement policy that included a new goal for refugee students. This study examines supports in both countries to consider whether they provide what is needed for the students to meet policy and humanitarian goals.

Perspective:

The perspective is one of social justice. Refugees arrive with highly diverse educational backgrounds ranging from strong to nonexistent. ESL courses have not always kept up with their needs (Woods, 2009). Refugees do not come to a new country because they choose to, but because they must flee for their lives. Countries that choose to resettle take on humanitarian obligations to help them be safe in their relocation. The 1951 Convention relating to Refugees and its 1967 Protocol include the right to an education. This study considers the various dimensions of education and ways in which the US and NZ attempt to address them for refugee-background students.

Methods:

This is a qualitative study. In 2014 I was an Ian Axford (NZ) Fellow in Public Policy and visited 10 schools and four after-school homework help centers in the key resettlement regions interviewing teachers, staff, and students. Previously, I have conducted research in Georgia and Florida examining school challenges and support. I have also done a thorough review of the countries’ policies to consider their philosophical underpinnings and subsequent directives. One major difference is that NZ is a welfare state and the US is not. However, social democracies such as NZ and Norway are reconsidering their benefits as world situations change regarding migrants and refugees. As mentioned, NZ created a new resettlement policy, and it emphasizes employment over other goals, much as the US has always done. For students, NZ has increased the expectation of students expected to complete secondary school with a level that will allow them to enter a post-secondary vocational or technical school. I will examine the supports in place and the comments of students and teachers in considering the rationale for this change. I will also compare the supports in place in both US and NZ contexts.

Data/evidence:

Data is drawn from interviews, focus groups, and document analyses in both the US and NZ. Participant data was obtained through IRB consent forms and digitally recorded, then transcribed. I used the online qualitative software Dedoose to create codes and look for themes.

In brief, I found NZ to be far more robust in its support for refugee-background students. I did not find an evidence-based rationale for their new goal for the students, and the country faces similar problems to that of the US, such as inadequate numbers of refugee tutors and liaisons. However, NZ, through its Ministry of Education and various schools, offers transparency and specific help for teachers and students for which there is no equivalent in the US. Teachers know in advance when they will receive a new refugee student so that they can prepare, in contrast to the complete lack of knowledge US teachers have, due to the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). Both countries offer supports, but NZ is more systematic and consistent, due to its ability to concentrate resettled refugees in six areas. As the country expands its resettlement regions, it is struggling with getting service to new areas.

Conclusions:

Overall, New Zealand teachers believe the new goal is noble but overly ambitious. They refer to Cummins’ (1986) research on language acquisition to contest the Ministry’s expectations. Some have indicated that the new, US-like reliance on standard assessments has caused both teachers and students to concentrate on the credentials, rather than what the students really need. Obviously, the US cannot completely replicate NZ’s policies, due to major differences in national size. But the US could learn from NZ policies.

Significance to CIE:

Resettlement countries have increased from 11 to 29 in recent years. New resettlement countries need models of best practice to provide the best humanitarian aid possible for refugee students and families.


 
References

Cummins, J. (1986). Empowering minority students: A framework for intervention. Harvard educational review, 56(1), 18-37.

Woods, A. (2009). Learning to be literate: Issues of pedagogy for recently arrived refugee youth in Australia. Critical Inquiry in Language Studies: An International Journal, 6(1-2), pp. 81-101.

Author