Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
With the continuous updating and improvement of bibliographic databases, such databases as WOS and Google Scholar have provided an important analytical basis for international teacher education research. In recent years, through these databases, scholars have mapped a network of scientific knowledge to conduct an in-deep analysis and interpretation of the hot subjects, research frontiers and emerging trends of international teacher education research, which enables a systematic and visualized presentation on the research progress and research trends of international teacher education.
Based on the WOS (Web of Science) database, this paper adopts five authoritative journals on teacher education and applies Citespace, a software for bibliographic metrology visualization, to draw a network map of the citation frequency of the five SSCI journals. To detect the evolution characteristics of the “central theme” and “central area” of the international teacher education research. This paper also employs the Google Fusion Tables to draw a map of distribution of the regions where international teacher education has been highly valued. Central themes of international teacher education research are cumulative. Central areas of international teacher education research center are divergently diffused from an institutional perspective while they are diversified and centralized from a national perspective. At present, the world's higher education research centers such as the United States, Australia and the Netherlands have already taken shape. China, not being a center for international teacher education, is far from those research centers in terms of academic influence, but the gap is gradually narrowing.
1: Evolution Characteristics of Central Themes of International Teacher Education Research
The CiteSpace software is applied to analyze the co-citation and spectral clustering of the quantity of literature from 1956 to 2017. The nodes of each year's clusters are arranged from high to low. Based upon the "Soup Shallow Phenomenon”, the software selects the top 25% of the research themes among all the clusters as central themes of the international teacher education research center of the year.
From 1956 to 1969, themes of international teacher education research center focused mainly on the study of such theories as social cognitive learning, social community and self-efficacy. From 1970 to 1989, themes shifted their focus on a practical level and they discuss the research objects covering pre-service teachers and mathematics teachers of education and training. Research methods became the main concern of themes of international teacher education research center from 1990 to 1999 and there were such central themes as narrative research, qualitative research and grounded research.
From 2000 to 2003, themes of research centers concentrated on teaching methods which center around adaptive teaching, reactive teaching and conversational modes. Since 2004, the number of international teacher education researches has greatly increased. Themes of research center has accumulated, which put emphasis on teacher professional development, empirical research, teacher learning, professional identity and self-efficacy. These central themes appear intermittently and they value classic researches in the field. In general, themes of international teacher education research center have shifted their attention from theoretical researches to practical researches, from a microscopic perspective to a macroscopic perspective, from a single research method to a combination of quantitative and qualitative research methods, from teaching methods of teachers to the improvement of the self-identification among teachers.
2: Evolution Characteristics of Central Areas of International Teacher Education Research Center
From an institutional perspective, central areas of international teacher education research are divergently diffused. From 1956 to 2003, institutions of international teacher education research centers were primarily located in the United States in North America, including Arizona State University, University of Missouri, University of North Carolina, and University of California. Beginning in 2004, international teacher education research centers have spread to Europe and Oceania which mainly include Ghent University, University of Helsinki, University of Queensland, University of Twente and University of Jyväskylä.
From a national perspective, central areas of international teacher education research are diversified and centralized. From 1956 to 2002, the United States is the dominant country of international teacher education research. In 2004, with the proliferation of literature on teacher education, research centers including United States, Australia, and the Netherlands, etc. have taken their shape. Currently, no countries in Asia belongs to the research centers.
In order to explore the formation characteristics of research center areas, countries where literature data have been produced from 1956 to 2017 are subject to visualized analysis to detect hot areas through the application of Google Fusion Tables. On the whole, hot areas of international teacher education research has spread from North America to Europe and Oceania, constituting a three-pronged situation. In 1989, the northeastern and western parts of the United States in North America has become hot areas for international teacher education research. From 1990 to 2014, hot areas of international teacher education research spread from North America to Europe. In 2015-2017, the southeastern part of Australia in Oceania has also become one of the hot areas and gradually, they spread to their neighboring countries and regions, thus forming a diversified hot area of international teacher education research. Among them, the United States, where international teacher education research is highly valued and the research in the country has won sustained popularity, is the leading country of the international teacher education and research center.
3: Influences of International Teacher Education Research Centers
Since the 21st century, quantity of literature on teacher education has increased sharply. Particularly after the output of the quantity of literature on teacher education exceeded 300 in 2004, it has increased stably. Among all the countries, the United States has a much larger volume of publications than other countries. It is the leading country among the international teacher education research centers. Netherlands and Australia are the non-leading countries of international teacher education research centers. As a leading country in the world's higher education research centers, the United States’ influence is so strong that it has now evolved from a unilateral pattern to a uni-multipolarity model. The country, where the quantity of literature and the quality of literature on teacher education are more advantageous, has long occupied the leading position among other research centers. As a non-leading country of the international teacher education research center, China's international influence has gradually increased, but its influence still lags behind other research centers. However, the gap is gradually narrowing.