Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Purpose:
The purpose of this study is to investigate the educational value of a study abroad program and determine how students’ cross-cultural views changed after studying abroad. The study focuses on the individual student's point of view. To analyze the educational value of a study abroad program, I used the conceptual framework of Adachi (2010). I conducted qualitative research and analyzed the results using the personal attitude construct (PAC) method (Naito, 1997); this included interviewing, assembling, and analyzing personal views using cluster analysis.
There is a tremendous amount of quantitative research regarding the educational value of study abroad programs, including large quantitative studies done by the Japanese Ministry of Education and the Japan Student Services Organization (JASSO). But we need to be mindful of some of the shortcomings of these large surveys. They tend to obscure the voices and experiences of the individual. Moreover, most of the survey questions are designed according to the researchers’ frameworks, and the outcomes tend to be interpreted based on the researchers’ value systems and external experiences. Therefore, I focused particularly on the following three methodological aspects 1) interviewing individual students who had experience studying overseas - not targeting large quantitative studies or generalizing the outcomes; 2) investigating the short-term and long-term influence of studying abroad on the cross-cultural views of students; and 3) creating a measurement tool/construct whereby students themselves can objectively, visually, and systematically evaluate the change in their beliefs and their personal growth after studying abroad.
Theoretical/Conceptual Framework:
Many studies verify the academic merit and educational value of studying abroad. For instance, Rubin and Sutton (2001) discussed the value of studying abroad from two reference points, academic (development of knowledge and skills) and non-academic (emotional, attitudinal, and personal growth). Kimura’s study (2011) specialized in language and found “evidence that growth was especially acknowledged with respect to listening ability.” Kimura also noted, "Since the use of learning strategies is also high, they will have more autonomy for English learning. " Adachi (2010) divided the educational value of studying abroad into four categories: 1) academic learning, 2) Ability to gain proficiency in a language, 3) acquisition of cross-cultural adaptability, and 4) human growth. After reviewing the literature, I partially adopted Adachi’s conceptual framework (2010) about the educational value of overseas programs. In addition to this framework, I will also discuss how many Japanese students currently study abroad, the current status of study abroad programs, the students’ English proficiency level, and the international experiences of Japanese students. I collected qualitative data from students before and after their study abroad program. At both time points, I conducted a PAC Analysis.
Method and Data:
PAC analysis is a well-known method in Japan; it was developed by Dr. Testuo Naito (1997). A number of qualitative research projects have been conducted using PAC analysis; and the Japanese scholar, Suetada (2001), noted that PAC analysis can potentially be used to develop a theory based on case studies. In this study, PAC analysis was implemented in three stages. First, I conducted a free association exercise using the following stimulus - “views when you think of foreigners and foreign countries.” By using a stimulus, associations were operationally obtained, i.e., derived from the subject’s frame of reference, not the researcher’s. Next, the subject was asked to evaluate the similarity between every pair of obtained items, thus allowing me to determine the psychological distance. Based on these results, I made a distance matrix which served as input for a cluster analysis. The dendrogram became the basis of common knowledge for further shared qualitative exploration.
Results:
In this presentation, I will show the dendrogram chart that was produced from the PAC analysis. Due to space constrains, I will briefly summarize the results. Based on the cluster analysis, several common findings emerged about the cross-cultural views of the students who returned from studying abroad. 1) Before studying abroad, most of their cross-cultural views came from Hollywood movies and TV programs that they had frequently watched. 2) The range of vocabulary and depth of explanations provided by the interviews were quite limited when students did not have much real-world experience with other cultures, i.e., prior to studying broad; their cross-cultural views and context for the interviews tended to be poorly worded. 3) Many of the students’ perceptions and fixed concepts of other cultures were powerfully influenced by media such as TV and movies. When they studied abroad, these images based on mass media were overwritten by their actual experiences.
This study highlights how viewers, in general, tend to get excited about shocking information regarding other cultures; therefore, TV Producers tend to create, exaggerate, and emphasize cultural differences and/or other aspects of a culture to impress viewers. In fact, programming content reflects the cultural viewpoints of its creators.
Significance:
International education is recognized as one of the most important issues in Japanese higher education. This study is significant because the research shows the educational value of a study abroad program from three different perspectives. The data showed 1) the reality of students’ cross-cultural views before the study abroad program, 2) how the study abroad program influenced students’ cross-cultural views, and 3) how studying abroad impacted students’ growth both on a personal level and in terms of intercultural competency, in a meaningful way. The data are still being analyzed. I will present more findings at the conference.
This work was supported by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports Science and Technology (MEXT) - JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP17K03017.