Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Southern Voices in Peace Education

Thu, April 18, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Seacliff B

Proposal

INTRODUCTION
As a field, peace education is as complex and contested as it is exciting and inspiring. Its literature yields no fixed definitions and there is an absence of any universal consensus on what constitutes peace education (Bar-Tal, 2002; Page, 2008; Salomon and Nevo, 2002; Trifonas and Wright, 2012). However, it can be broadly defined as a philosophy, process and pedagogy. As a philosophy, peace education emphasises love, compassion, empathy, harmony and nonviolence through education; as a process, it aims to replace cultures of violence with cultures of peace; as a pedagogy, it promotes a form of transformative learning to help individuals and societies acquire the skills, values, attitudes and behaviors required for peaceful living (Harris and Morrison, 2013; Reardon and Cabezudo, 2002).

Although peace education research critiques external values, institutions and structures in society that foster cultures of war, nonetheless internal critique of the field is relatively rare (Gur Ze’ev, 2001; Zembylas and Bekerman, 2013). This paper posits that, as part of its transformative intention, peace education must critically interrogate the cultural and structural violence embedded within its own theory and praxis. Thus, the current paper seeks to problematise assumptions and practices within peace education by examining the perspectives and lived experiences of peace educators from the Global South.

In the paper, we first review existing research according to four themes: concepts of peace and violence, critical peace education, postcolonialism, and teacher subjectivity. We then outline the design and methods of the investigation, discussing methodological strengths and limitations, and ethical concerns. Then, using relevant excerpts from interviews with participants we explore how their narratives demonstrate forms of discrimination and inequality in peace education today. The final discussion section concludes that peace education may have to challenge its own cultural and structural violence in order to become fully inclusive and transformational in the 21st century.

LITERATURE AND RQs
To situate this investigation within existing research and provide a rationale for conducting it, this paper reviews the literature on positive peace, structural and cultural violence, critical peace education, postcolonialism and subjectivity. Three epistemic issues emerge in the literature: relatively little self-critique of the internal workings of the field, a lack of perspectives from the Global South, and a lack of research on how Southern peace educators think, feel and experience the world while practicing their profession. Aiming to help address these gaps on a small scale, the remainder of the paper explores the perspectives and lived experiences of thirteen Southern peace educators to critique the cultural and structural violence subtly embedded within peace education. The investigation draws on the theoretical work of Connell’s Southern Theory, Bajaj’s critical peace education, and Galtung’s cultural violence to concentrate on three open-ended research questions: What do the perspectives and lived experiences of Southern peace educators reveal about the subjectivities of Southern scholars in peace education? What do the perspectives and lived experiences of Southern peace educators reveal about the classrooms where peace education is taught? What do the perspectives and lived experiences of Southern peace educators reveal about the cultures and institutional structures of peace education?

METHODS
The paper foregrounds the perspectives and lived experiences of peace educators in the Global South. We use a sample of thirteen semi-structured interviews with peace educators that formed part of interview data collected for a larger ethnographic case study with 25 peace scholars, and four interviews collected in a related study (Kester, 2017a, 2017b, 2017c, 2017d; 2017e; Kester and Cremin, 2017). These 13 particular interviews were selected from the set of 29 (11 from the set of 25 and 2 from the set of 4) because the participants originate from the Global South. The interviews included questions about the participants’ personal and professional histories, experiences, values, preferred styles of pedagogy and opinions on tensions within the field of peace studies. This project follows Wellington’s (2015, 139) principle that a ‘research interview’s function is to give a person, or a group of people, a voice’ and grant them a ‘platform’ to make ‘their views heard and eventually read’. Since it highlights the voices of educators from academically underrepresented regions, interviews as a mode of discussion and revelation was ideal.

The participant sample was diverse with regard to regional identity, gender, age, and professional experience with data for the study coming from lecturers from Argentina, Brasil, Colombia, Costa Rica, Egypt, Ethiopia, India, Malaysia, Peru, Philippines, and Somaliland. The small purposeful sample size helped provide an in-depth, detailed analysis of the participants’ views and experiences in a way that more generalised data could not (Rubin and Rubin, 2011). Data was analysed through an interpretive lens based on grounded theory.

FINDINGS
In this section, we draw on data collected over 26 hours of interview tape with the 13 participants. This process generated three themes germane to the study, which we review on three levels. At the level of the individual, we show that Global Southern peace educators perceive racial discrimination within the professional frameworks of peace education. In addition, their perceptions of intellectual labour suggest a metropole-periphery relationship between the Global North and South. Secondly, at the level of the classroom, neocolonial power imbalances seem to be replicated in the forms of discrimination and geographical stereotyping. Thirdly, at the level of the institution, linguistic inequalities are embedded within the expectations and trends underlying peace education courses. Different forms of cultural and structural violence thus emerge from the participants’ narratives. But, as well as problematising exclusionary structures within peace education, these findings also highlighted the potential of the field to build positive peace. The participants’ proactive measures to diversify curriculum and make learning processes inclusive, cross-cultural and dialogical demonstrate the scope of peace education to be truly global.

CONCLUSION
By giving a platform to a small sample of peace educators, we are aware that the specificity of this case study limits its generalisability to the vast field of peace education. However, it provides some insight into the contradictions and complexities of thought and praxis within the field. Peace education strives to transform worldviews and create peaceful societies (Clarke-Habibi, 2005; Lum, 2013), but it seems to be implicated, itself, in cultural and structural violence. This analysis of the narratives of Southern peace educators reveals myriad forms of discrimination, exclusion and power imbalances that must be challenged in the interests of building positive peace. Therefore, the paper suggests an exigency for peace education to be self-critical and question its own norms and assumptions. The field should decenter epistemic hegemonies and make its epistemologies, pedagogies, theories and institutions mindful of a range of voices and perspectives (Connell, 2013). In doing so, peace education can challenge hidden and intangible cultural and structural violence and build positive peace through transformative and decolonial peace education for the 21st century.

Authors