Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The idea of ‘distance’ in data-driven education: a productive critique

Wed, April 17, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview B

Proposal

In recent years the production and use of numerical data have become increasingly constitutive for the educational policy field inserting an evaluative rational guiding the way education is thought and acted out. In this paper this phenomenon, promoted by organizations such as UNESCO, the IEA and the OECD, is discussed in terms of ‘data-driven education’. Important research have already contributed to the critical examination of this development focusing on methodological issues, the accuracy of measurements as well as the way numerical data have come to shape and reshape the educational sector. Gorur (2015) has developed what she calls a ‘productive critique’ acknowledging the more fundamental questions such as ‘what kind of worlds are being brought into being, and what kinds of worlds do we want to create?’ However, I argue that still not enough attention has been paid to the main object of inquiry, namely education. For a critique of data-driven education to be productive it has to have the conceptual resources to address both the question of what is reconfigured and reduced, in terms of educational institutions, practices and knowledge, and of what alternative imaginaries and scenarios are at hand in terms of educational futures. The aim of this paper is to contribute to such a productive critique by examining the fundamental neoliberal idea of ‘distance’ as expressed in the context of data-driven education drawing on Porter (1995), research on data-driven education and non-affirmative educational theory. The critique evolves around three aspects of distance in data-driven education also structuring the text; these are spatial-, methodological and relational distance. Each aspect is examined in two steps. The first step is deconstructive in character and draws on earlier research on data-driven education and the second step is reconstructive in character and draws on non-affirmative education theory (Uljens & Ylimaki, 2017). The paper concludes discussing the idea of distance in data-driven education as highly normative, prescribing a very specific and narrow understanding of education and by no means being as objective and disinterested as it sets out to be. Non-affirmative education theory is then finally presented as an invitation to a widened discussion, offering a conceptual repertoire facilitating a more elaborated discussion on alternative imaginaries, but without prescribing solutions already decided in advance.

Author