Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Short-Term Faculty Exchange Programs: Is Mutuality Experienced in South-North Academic Partnerships?

Tue, April 16, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Atrium (Level 2), Boardroom C

Proposal

Background for the Study
“We live in a globalized world but not in a homogeneously globalized world”.
(Santos, 2012, p.9)

Inter-institutional collaborations between the Global North and the Global South tend to be unequal in nature; power relations play an important role in defining the distribution of the costs and benefits of such collaborations. The current global imaginary situates the North as the center and aspiration for development (Stein & Andreotti, 2017). Within the higher education arena, internationalization is not neutral (Castiello-Gutiérrez & Lee, 2017; Maldonado-Maldonado, 2006) and has the potential of representing “a continuation of former imperial and political connections that have evolved into financially beneficial markets and sources of income for Western universities particularly in the US and the UK” (Bolsmann & Miller, 2008, p. 80).

Higher education institutions (HEIs) collaborate internationally for purposes that can be broadly classified as economic, political, cultural, and educational (de Wit, 1995). When internationalization is studied outside of just the institutional level, scholars have found it can also become a source of national soft power with the ability to reinforce hegemonic traditions (Altbach & de Wit, 2015; Collins & Rhoads, 2010; Lee, 2014; Trilokekar, 2010). Some institutions also see internationalization as a strategy to position themselves as leaders in their national and regional space (Castiello-Gutiérrez et al, 2016).

Regardless of these imperialistic views of internationalization of higher education, some scholars argue that there is room for mutually beneficial partnerships that could move cooperation from a state of ‘transnational greed’ to one of ‘transnational solidarity’ (Santos, 2012, p. 10) and that public good and market-like behaviors of HEIs can intersect and coexist (Marginson, 2016; Mars & Rhoades, 2012; Poloma, 2017). Nevertheless, it seems that this intersection is more likely to happen at the program level rather than at the broader and more complex institutional or national levels. Program level collaboration among HEIs can be more egalitarian if partnerships are based on the concept of mutuality, which Galtung (1980) described as a countermeasure to imperialism and a framework for establishing more ethical and balanced cooperation mechanisms between the Global South and the Global North. According to Galtung (1980), to achieve mutuality, institutions or individuals need to engage in four principles. The first one –equity– refers to a positive-sum of benefits and a mutual agreement on the aims of cooperation. The second one –autonomy– refers to a mutual respect for each partner’s values, knowledge, norms, ways of knowing, and beliefs. The third one –solidarity– refers to a level of interconnectedness among partners for mutual support. Finally, the principle of participation refers to partnership engagement that is not hierarchical or stratified. A relationship where mutuality is present shows connection, understanding, involvement, communication, respect and, while the exchange might not be equivalent on both sides, the willingness and commitment of both parties to pursue a common goal (Henson, 1997).

Using this lens, the authors analyzed the experiences of faculty members from Mexico and their peers in the United States and Canada who jointly teach a course as part of an international short-term mobility program to understand, whether or not and to what extent, can programs such as these help promote South-North academic relationships based on mutuality.

Methodology
To answer these questions, we conducted a qualitative study analyzing interviews and open-ended questionnaires. Participants were selected from a group of faculty members who participated in a short-term exchange program coordinated by the Consortium for North American Higher Education Collaboration (CONAHEC), a large membership-based international higher education network. CONAHEC opened a call for proposals and invited faculty from member institutions to participate. Mexican faculty members who participate in this program are matched with a colleague in either the US or Canada to collaborate and partially co-teach a class. Each professor is expected to travel to the partner institution for a week during the semester, where they will teach lectures and meet with other faculty members to discuss potential projects, among other activities. Professors will also design an online activity so that students from both countries can collaborate.

The sample for this study consisted of 19 faculty members who participated in the program between spring 2017 and spring 2018. Elements of analysis included participants’ activity-planning documents, responses to a follow-up survey of their participation in the program and interviews especially designed for this study. Data collected were analyzed and coded to identify to what extent the concept of mutuality was present in their answers. Using Galtung’s (1980) aforementioned principles, and adapting Leng’s (2016) refined mutuality framework, we created a rubric to facilitate the interview process and data analysis phases.

Preliminary Findings
The preliminary findings illustrate the presence of some traits of the four components of the concept of mutuality in the relationships established among the surveyed academics:
● Equity (mutual agreement and cooperatively collaboration) was present from the start of the application process. Both HEIs sign an equal commitment to support their faculty members, which enables an equitable and leveled plainfield for collaborations.
● Autonomy (respect for knowledge, educational norms, academic values, ways of knowing and beliefs) was also present in some cases. A quote from a US professor helps to further illustrate this concept: “I was very impressed with how my host...and his colleagues are taking care of their undergraduate students… I was also impressed with the amount of outreach activities they are doing, it was an inspiration for me”
● Solidarity (strong links, interconnectedness and continuous communication) seemed to be a constant in the participants’ journey towards a common goal: “We are not alone we are working in a continuous effort [...] to find: academic excellence.”
● Participation (non-hierarchical full involvement in project activities) was illustrated by one of the faculty members: “We are planning to mentor an undergraduate student together, she may go for a few weeks to [Mexico] over the summer. If not, we will work remotely...”.

We are confident that further analysis will contribute to a better understanding of how traits of mutuality benefit collaboration and help promote equality and respect in academic relationships.

Authors