Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This presentation develops Lee Shulman's theory of pedagogical content knowledge by paying particular attention to the ways in which Shulman's categories of teacher’s knowledge are constructing when viewed from the perspective of curriculum integration.
Curriculum integration has been a part of discussions on school development since the beginning of modern schooling. The most notable advocate of curriculum integration has probably been John Dewey who continues to be a frequently referred author in the field. New waves of interest has been coming and going for decades. Recently, curriculum integration has been introduced as a normative element in the core curriculum of Finnish basic education. Therefore, new research on curriculum integration is currently taking place in Finland.
The need for integration in schoolwork has been argued in many ways. Subject-divided school day has been criticized as creating a fragmented learning experience for students. As lessons are dealing different topics and perhaps changing in every 45 minutes, it is difficult to generate deep and meaningful learning. However, it has been claimed that learning is constructing better if it is purposefully connected to something previously learned or put into some larger whole. To know what climate change is, is a good example of an integrated curriculum as a truly necessary approach. If one wants to know the phenomenon of climate change and the concept of sustainability as an attempt to provide a solution, the causes, processes and effects of climate change has to be explained multidisciplinarily.
Previous experiences show that although curriculum integration has been an objective in the Finnish curricula of the basic education since the 70s, implementation has been difficult. It seems like the same ideas are introduced repeatedly, but not cumulatively based on previous experience and research. At first, the most fundamental questions are; how schools can implement curriculum integration if knowledge of the idea is vague and it has not had any significant role in teacher education?
Curriculum integration is a broad concept that often refers to interdisciplinary schoolwork, overcoming the boundaries of differentiated school subjects, and which is today often associated in Finland with the concept of phenomenal learning, which is a student-centered approach to the idea. In Finland, curriculum integration has been considered as a challenging task especially for subject teachers who have expertise in teaching a few subjects in contrast with primary school teachers who are teaching almost all subjects.
Shulman's theory of pedagogical content knowledge stresses the importance of teachers’ knowledge of the content of the studies. With sufficient content knowledge, a teacher can develop content specific pedagogical knowledge that is referred as pedagogical content knowledge. That means suitable examples, metaphors, assignments, or presentations, among other things, that can make what is taught comprehensible for students. General pedagogical knowledge is not enough. According to Shulman, a professional teacher also has knowledge of what are the common misinterpretations in the studies and what parts are especially difficult to learn. The presupposition for this is that the teacher knows the content well enough to be able to build one’s own pedagogical toolbox and wisdom of practice.
In the case of curriculum integration, the question arises; how teachers, especially subject teachers, can implement successful teaching in an area where they do not have in-depth knowledge of the content? This issue is emphasized in the student-based approaches, which involves phenomenal learning. If the core content of the learning process arises from the experiences of the students, how a teacher can apply well-developed pedagogical content knowledge? Additionally, teachers face challenges in curricular knowledge; to what extent subject teachers are aware of the curricular content of other subjects than their own and how much they know about what the students are learning outside their own classrooms? For successful curriculum integration that is based on knowledge, a teacher would need to know the both sides of the river on which the bridge is built.
Shulman’s theory reveals why curriculum integration is a demanding task for teachers. Shulman originally mentioned seven major categories of teacher’s knowledge that act as the foundation for successful teaching. These categories are: 1) general pedagogical knowledge, 2) knowledge of learners, 3) knowledge of educational contexts, 4) knowledge of educational ends, purposes and values, 5) content knowledge, 6) curriculum knowledge, and 7) pedagogical content knowledge. Later a new category of technological pedagogical content knowledge have been added generating wide-ranging research interest. Now, Shulman’s theory is developed by creating another category of teacher’s knowledge called integrative pedagogical knowledge. It is not an independent category of teacher’s knowledge, but an approach to each category from the perspective of curriculum integration.
To develop better preparedness for teachers to integrate the curriculum, integrative pedagogical knowledge should be a part of teacher education. In our theoretical study leaning on Shulman, we located the minimum requirements of teachers’ knowledge that the successful implementation of curriculum integration would require: 1) knowledge of curriculum integration as a possibility for constructing a curriculum, 2) knowledge of concepts bridging different subjects, 3) knowledge of the purposes of curriculum integration, and 4) knowledge of collaborative teaching by subject teachers. (Niemelä & Tirri, 2018)
Based on the theoretical formulations, an empirical study has begun to examine the actualization of teachers’ integrative pedagogical knowledge in teacher education. The objective of the empirical study is to operationalize the created theoretical framework for revealing the level of knowledge pre-service teachers have on curriculum integration and how it develops during in-class training period including an integrated project. At the time of the presentation, at least preliminary results of the study can probably be briefly shown.
Niemelä, M. A., & Tirri, K. (2018). Teachers’ Knowledge of Curriculum Integration: A Current Challenge for Finnish Subject Teachers. In Y. Weinberger & Z. Libman (Eds.), Contemporary Pedagogies in Teacher Education and Development. London: InTech.