Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Micro-level cost-benefit approach to doctoral degree fraud in Ukraine
With the broadening discussion of new forms of knowledge creation and transfer in the globalized economy, the issue of a global PhD comes to the fore, while the quality of doctoral education remains of concern. As globalization in education proliferates, so does corruption, including in doctoral education. This study investigates doctoral degree fraud by researching the supply side of ghost written dissertations and matches it with the benefits that potential clients receive from buying doctorates. Specifically, this study researches the market of writing and defending doctoral dissertations in Ukraine. The case of Ukraine is of interest for at least two reasons. First, Ukraine has a highly corrupt education sector. Second, all doctorates in Ukraine are conferred by the state, and thus holders of doctorates have equal rights on numerous benefits, including appointment, promotion, pay scales, housing and such.
Cost-benefit analysis is used in public economics as well as in numerous other disciplines and interdisciplinary fields to evaluate large public projects. The process of informed decision-making is at the core of cost-benefit analysis. On the macro-level, cost-benefit analysis focuses not only on direct and immediate costs and benefits, but also on benefits to the society, in the broad sense. These effects include positive and/or negative externalities. On the micro-level, benefits to the individual or internal benefits are of primary concern. Thus, the micro-level cost-benefit approach implies individual considerations in decision-making in regards to a given project or opportunity. This study offers cost-benefit approach to the problem of dissertations-for-sale. The discussion of price structures in the corrupt market of dissertations-on-order is counterpoised with the structure of individual benefits expected by those ordering dissertations.
The cost of acquiring a dissertation and/or other necessary scholarly works may be considered an investment. This investment may bring return within just a few years, as would be the case with CSc degree, or in the long run, as would be the case with DSc degree, in the form of higher salary, better professional position, and higher illicit income. There is a two-tier system of doctoral degrees in Ukraine, including candidate sciences (CSc) and doctor sciences (DSc). A DSc dissertation relates to the more prestigious degree and thus requires a significantly more complex work. Less than one out of six CSc holders ever defend a DSc dissertation. Peer pressure adds to the demand for ghost written dissertations. If a faculty member wants to be respected by colleagues, he/she has to earn at least a CSc degree or even DSc degree. Formal demands to non-degree holding faculty and prospective faculty come from the university administration. University rectors urge faculty members to acquire doctoral degrees as soon as possible, because they are necessary for state licensing and accreditation.
This study of the “dissertations for sale” market was conducted by first identifying providers of the service, as well as types of services they offer, and prices they charge. This study excluded individuals that offer similar services, focusing only on firms. Dissertations are specific products, tailored to specific clients to match their individual needs. This specificity, combined with the illicit nature of the product, makes the dissertations market unique and distinct from other markets that offer standardized products and services for mass consumption. Firms that offer dissertations for sale are included in the category of providers of intellectual and educational services. These firms work legally by offering intellectual services, including custom-made dissertations on order, and have no reason to hide from law enforcement agencies.
This study identified the total of forty-six private for-profit firms that offer dissertations for sale. Such dissertations on order services are accompanied by offerings of all other services needed to qualify for a doctorate. These firms do not limit their offerings to any particular discipline or a group of disciplines, providing the clients with scholarly works in any discipline, from most popular Economics and Law to most expensive Medical sciences.
CSc degree and academic rank of associate professor that follows add fifteen and twenty-five percent to the base salary, respectively. If the base monthly salary of the departmental associate professor is equal to $200, then fifteen and twenty-five percent additions would mean the total of $280. Although these are before tax salaries, the addition is substantial. In just five years, this additional pay for the degree and academic rank would mean extra $5,000 or $4,000 after tax. Given the average price for a ghost written CSc dissertation of $2,810, this makes the cost a good investment. Even taking into consideration the related costs, the forty percent salary increase would cover the cost of it in just six years. Afterwards, it will turn into pure profit.
The cost of a DSc dissertation is much higher than that of CSc, the average of $13,448, but the benefits are higher as well. DSc degree and academic rank of professor that follows add twenty-five and thirty-three percent to the base salary, respectively. These additional pay rates sum up in a fifty-eight percent salary increase. If the base monthly salary of the departmental professor is equal to $250, then the fifty-eight percent increase would mean $145, increasing the total monthly salary to $395. In just ten years, this additional pay for the DSc degree and academic rank of professor would mean extra $17,400 or $13,500 after tax. Given the average price for a ghost written DSc dissertation of $13,448, this makes buying a DSc dissertation good investment. Taking into consideration al related costs, the fifty-eight percent salary increase would cover the cost only in around twenty years.
Given the slow pace, lack of persistency and consistency of the reforms, Ukraine is not likely to join the global processes of creation and transfer of knowledge. What other countries can learn from Ukraine’s struggles is that a centralized system of state control does not safeguard from doctoral degrees being sold on the open market. On the contrary, the overwhelming corruption helps trade in dissertations as long as personal benefits exceed the costs of acquiring a doctorate.