Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Unheard Stories of Canadian Immigrant Muslim Students Living in Liminal Spaces.

Tue, April 16, 10:00 to 11:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific B

Proposal

Abstract
This paper presents results from a study which investigated Muslim elementary school students’ classroom experiences in Canadian schools. The results filled the gap in the literature regarding Muslim elementary school students’ experiences in Canadian mainstream schools. The study uses an interpretive inquiry approach in which the interpretation of the dialogues with children about their lived experiences of schooling served as a foundation for critical analysis. Data from Muslim immigrant children currently attending mainstream Canadian schools is presented. For data analysis, the analysis of narratives method is used in which the data is collected in the form of stories.

Purpose and Content: Over the past 20 years different views on Muslims’ presence in the West have posed questions about Muslim integration, their identity, culture, religion, and education and have positioned Muslims as outliers among the other immigrant groups (Niyozov & Pluim, 2009). Specifically, the worldwide spread post-9/11 phenomenon named “Islamophobia” or more recently “xeno-racism” contributes to ostracizing of Muslim communities, instilling fear or hatred of Islam and leads to individual, ideological or systemic forms of oppression and discrimination in Western states (Abu-Laban & Dhamoon, 2009; Fekete, 2004). In Canada, education as the most “national” of institutions has traditionally been seen as having an obligation to provide continuity and content to the ongoing dialogue about the nature of multiculturalism, and the management of diversity. This role is increasingly challenged by the societal attitudes towards Muslims. Multicultural education (Chinnery, 2007a, 2007b; Gillette & Boyle-Baise, 1996; Larkin & Sleeter, 1995; McCain & Salas, 2001; Moodley, 2001; Tilley, 2006), in its current form is not catering to the needs of racially, culturally and religiously diverse Canadian classroom population. Racism and discrimination in Western schools are not uncommon and create unwelcoming learning environments for minority students who might feel singled out and ignored (Ghosh & Abdi, 2004). The school discourses have biases which spread racism and other forms of marginalization and also create systems of advantage and disadvantage. Because of the widespread negative stereotypes about Muslims (Karim, 2008; McCoy et al., 2011; Zine, 2001, 2006, 2007 Abu El-Haj, 2002), there is a possibility that Muslim children have difficulty in their social interactions with their peers and teachers (Hoot, Szecsi & Moosa, 2003; Zine, 2008a, 2008b). Schools are often the only social sites where young Muslim children have a chance to interact with the mainstream culture without any interference from their parents and family. The quality and kind of these children’s school experiences shape their future integration into the society-at-large which, according to Canadian Multiculturalism Act (2005), is necessary for social inclusion and societal cohesion.While these outcomes for Muslim children are well researched in teenage years, there is no research exploring the experiences of younger, elementary-aged children, specifically in the public schools of Edmonton despite of the growing immigrant population of the city (Statistic Canada, 2011). To fill this gap in the literature my study explores school experiences of seven foreign-born Muslim immigrant children. The study used an interpretive inquiry approach in which the interpretation of dialogues from interviews with Muslim immigrant children and youth who were born outside of Canada and are currently attending mainstream Canadian schools about their lived experiences of schooling served as a foundation for critical analysis of school culture. These two to three interviews with each participant were took place over the course of one year. The interviews used pre-interview activities and mainly open-ended questions (Ellis, 2006; Ellis, Hetherington, Lovell, McConaghy, & Viczko, 2013.) For data analysis, I used “narrative analysis” (Polkinghorne, 1995) to first create individual narrative portraits followed by what Polkinghorne describes as “analysis of narratives” to examine selected experiences across all participants.

Theoretical Grounding: Critical pedagogy (Freire, 1985; Giroux, 1997; Greene, 1988; Kozol, 2006; MacLaren, 2010) informs my study about Muslim children’s school experiences. Critical pedagogues have a special point of view about today’s schooling and question the knowledge produced in schools and its effect on students coming from diverse backgrounds. Critical pedagogy provides a critical framework to review Muslim children’s school experiences with the understanding of deeply rooted issues of power, race and politics (Darder, Baltodano & Torres, 2009; MacLaren, 2010). The knowledge transmitted by schools and power prevalent in society have a very close relationship with each other (Apple, 2000; Banks, 1991, 1996, 1999, 2001, 2010). Since issues of race, class, power, and gender are central to critical theorists’ approaches to the study of schooling, mainstream schooling supports a bias which results in the reinforcement of the dominant culture (Darder, Baltodano & Torres, 2009; MacLaren, 2010). From this theoretical perspective, schools perpetuate the hegemonic processes that create cultural and economic domination of the mainstream culture in society through the reproduction of ideological hegemony among students (Gramsci, 1971, 1992; McLaren, 2010). According to the critical theory perspective, the main aspect of belonging is that it is usually controlled by power relations and includes individuals who have the power to include or exclude others whom they think are not valuable or worthy of belonging to that particular group. The dominant group in any society sets the terms for the participation of the minority ethnic groups in the larger society. The segregationist politics from the dominant group could lead to the separation of culturally and ethnically diverse groups. The school culture could, therefore, work to not only support students from the dominant classes, but also exclude the experiences and dreams of subordinate groups (Freire, 1985; Giroux, 1983; Greene, 1988; Kozol, 2006).

Significance: A large number of refugees and immigrants from Muslim regions are coming to Canada due to war, poverty and several other reasons. Their migration has resulted in an increase in the Muslim student population in Canadian schools specifically in early childhood settings. This rise put new demands on the Canadian education system. The current global situation and media’s projection of Muslims as terrorists since 9/11 raised the importance of addressing the issues related to the Muslim community, especially for younger students whose responses to such messages and the resulting attitudes toward them have not been studied. If not addressed in the early years of schooling, issues of religious discrimination can create isolation among Muslim students, negatively affect their chances for success, and reduce their chances of integration into the dominant culture (McCoy et al., 2011; Ward, & Kus, 2012; Zine, 2006). This may also contribute to radicalization of Muslim youth who may fall prey to extremist groups and organizations. Schools are often the only social sites where young Muslim children have a chance to interact with the mainstream culture without any interference from their parents and family. The quality and kind of these children’s school experiences shape their future strategies of acculturation, both in school and in broader society. The presentation of the results of my study could help researchers, teachers, school administrations, and policymakers understand the role schools can play in the development of the children’s hybrid identities as Muslim Canadians. At a broader level, the results could also contribute to our understanding of the complexities involved in addressing the needs of children from diverse cultural and religious backgrounds.

Author