Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Objectives and purposes
On June 20, 2018, President Donald Trump issued an executive order temporary repealing a “zero tolerance” policy of separating immigrant children and families crossing into the United States. This reversal of policy positions followed a rare showing of public unity among seemingly disparate political groups opposed to family separations. Evangelicals, Methodists, the Business Roundtable, U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and Republicans joined many liberal Democrats and immigrant rights and advocacy organizations to condemn the Trump Administration’s zero tolerance policy. This “national outcry” (Williamson & Nixon, 2018, June 20) culminated in the largest single fundraiser in Facebook history, which raised over $20 million for Texas-based Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services (RAICES) and included donations from over a half-million people across more than 30 countries (Guynn, 2018, June 25). In an era of deep political division, how can we account for this temporal demonstration of national unity and this shift in policy positions by a typically uncompromising administration?
We approach the Trump Administration’s repeal of family separations as an illustrative case for understanding policy making in a “post truth” era in which emotional appeals outweigh scientific evidence in the education of publics (McIntyre, 2018). Combining Critical Policy Analysis (CPA) and affect studies, we analyzed 184 print media texts from the three most widely circulated newspapers (New York Times, Wall Street Journal, and USA Today). We asked: Between President Trump’s declaration of the zero tolerance policy and the eventual repeal of his executive order, how did major news media outlets construct emotional proximities between readers and immigrant youth and families? Additionally, we explored how shame and emotional manipulation have historically served as a particular form of legitimizing political action and as an enduring process of (mis)educating the public about policy. We suggest that in order to fully explore CIES’ Theme of Education for Sustainability, we must also examine and interrogate such forms of education that have sustained and reified contemporary policies across the globe with material consequences for children and their families. We offer one empirical U.S. example.
Theoretical Framework
Critical Policy Analysis (CPA) offers one powerful approach for conducting an inquiry of zero tolerance (Diem et al., 2014). CPA explores policy as an ongoing sociocultural “practice of power”: how policies circulate in multiple directions and how a broad array of interpretive actors “make” new norms, activities, and practices (Levinson, Sutton, & Winstead, 2009, p. 767). Informed by CPA, we explored how journalists participate in “making” policy by authoring and disseminating texts that invite publics to agree, refute, and resist zero tolerance policies.
To sharpen our analyses of the productive role of media, we turned to studies of affect and emotion. Paying attention to the productive potential of affect—those nameable and unnamable sensations and dispositions that mediate social action (Ahmed, 2013; McKenzie, 2017; Stewart, 2007)—is particularly important in “post-truth” contexts (McIntyre, 2018). Tracing the politics of emotion offers one way to analyze and explain the formation of political coalitions, the surge in national protests, and ultimately, the reversal of zero tolerance.
Methods & Public Data
Given our interests in acquiring a broad national sense of how media invited publics to feel, we prioritized three of the most widely circulated U.S. newspapers: USA Today, The New York Times, and The Wall Street Journal. We bound our media search of zero tolerance by our focused timeline of inquiry (May 2018 – June 2018). In total, we acquired 184 print media texts (see Appendix B). We imported all texts into qualitative data analysis software, NVivo 11. We began by developing “InVivo” codes—themes developed using verbatim text. We coded for how media texts framed immigrant youth, zero tolerance policy, and our primary interests in emotional (dis)connections.
Augmenting and Channeling Shame: Crying Children in Cages
Although the Trump Administration used the language of “detention centers” to describe zero tolerance policies, media circulated stories that reframed zero tolerance as a dehumanizing and criminal policy of imprisoning kids in cages. A few examples include: “children in chainlink cages” (Fernandez & Benner, 2018 June 22) and “Border Patrol processing cages” (Henninger, 2018 June 20). In parallel with this reframing of zero tolerance, media circulated and legitimated depictions of immigrant children as “anxious, depressed, crying” (McKinley, Robbins, Correal, 2018 June 22). Notably, even defenders of zero tolerance reified a “crying child” frame. Conservative commentator Ann Coulter, derogatorily referred to migrant children as “child actors weeping and crying on all the other networks 24/7 right now” (Colin & Hsu, 2018 June 20). These accusations ironically reconstituted images of crying children and perpetuated mainstream policy framings.
Shaming Zero Tolerance and Crafting Untenable Policy Positions
Framed by media coverage of crying children in cages, zero tolerance became a shameful policy to endorse. Goldberg (2018 June 19) described the Trump Administration as “having the capacity for shame” and as “complicit in something vile.” Notably, feelings of shame transcended political boundaries and forged seemingly impossible coalitions—from former first lady, Rosalyn Carter to Republican Senator Orrin Hatch of Utah. Additionally, shame reflected the very emotional intensities that sparked over 600 #KeepFamiliesTogether protests across the nation (McCausland, Guadalupe, & Rosenblatt, 2018 June 30). In addition to popular protest signs that read, “No child should be kept in a cage,” protesters yelled, “Shame! Shame! Shame!” (Raice, Barrett, Duehren, 2018, June 30). In many ways, shaming defenders of zero tolerance and feeling ashamed of the nation mobilized public action and transformed support of zero tolerance into an untenable political stance.
Scholarly Significance
This paper illustrates the significance of affect and emotion as critical resources in educating publics and mobilizing political action and policy change. Following Petersen (2011) we argue that “Rather than advocate a less passionate politics, we should better understand the politics of our passions” (p. 163). Based on our analyses, mediating and legitimating shame in ways that sparked national outcry manifested material and policy change. Further research might explore how to translate affective moments (see Appendix A) into long-term, sustainable, and intergenerational struggles to advance more humane and just worlds.
Ethan Chang, University of California, Santa Cruz
Jill Koyama, University of Arizona
Julie Kasper, University of Arizona