Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
The rural-urban education gap has been an enduring problem in China. The rapid and extensive education reform dating from the early 1980s have brought dramatic improvements in expanding access of basic education throughout the country (UNESCO, 2015). Despite the near-universal completion of primary education has been achieved (see Table 1), sharp rural-urban inequality in learning outcomes still persists. Specifically, rural-urban literacy gap is documented in J. Wang and Li (2008)’s case study that approximately 50% children from rural schools performed below the minimum literacy requirements, whereas less than 10% students in urban schools did. UNESCO (2015) indicated that rural-urban educational inequality has transformed from inequality of opportunity into an implicit form of outcome inequality.
This rural-urban literacy gap is poorly understood by a few small sampled, qualitative studies (D. Wang, 2013; J. Wang & Li, 2008). Only recently, Author (2018)’s cross-sectional survey study found that students in rural schools performed significantly lower (1.14 S.D.) than students from urban schools on a standardized literacy test. However, it is skeptical whether this observed literacy gap is due to rural-urban regional inequality or capital inequality led by uneven distribution of family Socioeconomic Status (SES) in rural and urban regions. Additional study is required to confirm the significance of rural-urban inequality in literacy learning.
Moreover, few studies explored the developmental pattern of the rural-urban literacy gap. Luo et al. (2012) suggested that the literacy gap emerged as early as three-year old when children started to learn literacy skills in kindergarten. Students probably enter rural and urban schools with an existing literacy gap, which may grow with grade and trap rural residents in low educational attainment and low-paying jobs later in life. Therefore, understanding the development of rural-urban literacy gap at the first stage of formal education is crucial for preventing the intergenerational transmission of inequality.
This study explores the rural-urban literacy gap by four research questions:
• What is the size of the rural-urban literacy gap in primary education?
• Does rural-urban literacy gap exist after removing the influence of family SES?
• Does rural-urban literacy gap follow a cumulative or compensatory developmental pattern with family SES controlled?
• Does family SES affect students’ literacy learning differently in rural and urban regions?
Data come from Rural-Urban Literacy Gap (RULG). Literacy development of 3408 primary students from 26 rural and urban primary schools was assessed three times over two academic years. Parental education and family income were collected by parent survey. Multivariate Analysis of Covariance was performed to examine rural-urban literacy gap with family effect removed. Then Latent Growth Curve Modeling and multigroup analysis were conducted to examine the growth pattern of this gap and the family’s impact on the growth rate of literacy development in rural and urban schools (Figure 3)
Results revealed that (1) the observed overall rural-urban literacy gap was about 0.56 SD to 0.79 SD (Figure 1 and Figure 2). This rural-urban literacy gap was statistically significant at the onset of formal education (0.2 S.D.) and was widening over years of schooling (0.7 to 1.1 S.D.). (2) The rural-urban literacy gap adjusted by family SES remains statistically significant. This finding substantiates the existence of rural-urban regional inequality in literacy learning. The observed rural-urban literacy gap is not solely the result of uneven distribution of family SES, rural-urban regional inequality is also involved in producing it.
Modeling results indicated that (3) both initial level and growth rate of literacy outcome were significantly lower for students in rural schools than in urban schools. The rural-urban literacy gap is thus cumulative and developing over years of primary schooling (Figure 3). (4) Surprisingly, the multigroup analysis showed that family SES effect was significantly stronger on both initial level and growth rate of students from urban schools, however, was rather mild on the initial level and growth rate of students in rural schools (Figure 4). Put in other words, urban students benefit more from higher family socioeconomic status than both rural and county students do. Living and receiving formal education in urban regions can reinforce the impact of family SES on literacy learning. This suggested that students attend rural schools are more likely to achieve lower literacy than urban students who come from the same family SES, moreover, rural students also have the tendency to be left further behind urban counterparts in the subsequent years of primary education.
This study calls attention to the rural-urban regional inequality in literacy learning outcome in early school years. Additional researches should be conducted and policy initiatives should be taken to narrow the rural-urban literacy gap as early as possible with the ultimate goal of ending educational inequality. Obviously, as this study shows, China has a long way to go in this direction.