Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Silent borrowing by latecomers to competences: US proponents of 21st century skills

Wed, April 17, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific J

Proposal

This paper argues that United States has come “late” to the transnational movement to establish competences as elementary and secondary learning goals, and that US proponents of competences borrow but borrow “silently” from the transnational movement (Waldow, 2009).
Proponents of “key competences,” which US reformers call “21st century skills” or “deeper learning,” do not agree on exactly which skills and dispositions students should acquire. However, they do agree that to prepare for the “new knowledge economy,” students need to acquire interpersonal and intrapersonal as well as cognitive competences that transcend or complement disciplinary knowledge.
Informed by discursive institutionalism and by the assumption that the agency of individual actors and organizations matters (Kaasch & Martens, 2015), I focus on competences as traveling policy at the level of nations and intra-nation polities. My methods included critical discourse analysis of key documents, tracing of citations, and timelines identifying temporal sequences.
Key supporters of 21st century skills include corporations, particularly technology corporations keen to develop computer-based assessment of competences. Another key player is the National Research Council (NRC), a nonprofit government-sanction organization whose 2013 report on 21st century skills was supported by Pearson and other foundations.
These US reformers started “late” in the sense that the main promoter, the Partnership for 21st Century Skills (P21), was founded only in 2002, whereas polities like Francophone Belgium, Quebec, and France were already incorporating competences into their curricula by 2000–2005 (Anderson-Levitt, 2017) if not, like Sweden, by the 1990s (Sundberg & Wahlström, 2012). The United States, lacking a national curriculum, has not yet instituted competences, although two-thirds of its states currently subscribe to its 2010 Common Core State Standards, and some reformers make the contested claim that these standards incorporate several 21st century skills (NRC, 2013).
I claim that some US reformers “borrowed” from the transnational movement because they occasionally cite OECD documents, and because they use language like the OECD’s to describe the problem and its solution. Indeed, NRC explicitly borrows the term “competencies” from OECD 2005 (NRC 2013, p. 23). However, US reformers borrowed “silently” (Waldow 2009) by distancing themselves from non-US actors. NRC (2013) describes the OECD and its members not as inspiration for US actions, but merely as engaged in a parallel movement. In the most read US documents (Casner-Lotto & Barrington 2006; Trilling & Fadel, 2009; NRC 2013), almost 97% of the references are to US-based reports and studies, and only 4 out of 559 citations refer to international organizations. In addition, these documents refer only minimally to US performance on PISA.
This study matters because it offers the case of a policy flowing to rather than from the United States. It also supports the argument that the discourse of international organizations, here the OECD, can be influential, at least indirectly (e.g., Stone, 2014). However, it supports even more strongly the argument that large corporations are major promoters of the competences movement in the United States (e.g., Morgan, 2016) as in Europe (Laval et al. 2012).

Author