Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Instructional Leadership and Teachers' Intent to Leave: A Comparative Study between Arab and Jewish Schools

Mon, April 15, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific O

Proposal

Theoretical Background and Proposed Model
Teacher's intent to leave is a withdrawal behavior, which refers to a set of attitudes and behaviors adopted when teachers stay at a job but for some reason decide to be less participative (Kaplan, Bradley, Lachman, & Hayness, 2009). Teachers’ withdrawal behaviors are very costly and result in decreased school standards (Shapira-Lishchinsky, 2012). Research in the last few decades has consistently shown that principals are powerful players who can affect school effectiveness and bring about change (e.g., Sun & Leithwood, 2017). A growing scholarly literature has attempted to explore the possible links between various leader actions and behavioral outcomes for teachers, including burnout, intent to leave and turnover (Van Maele & Van Houtte, 2014)





In this comparative study, we tested and compared an innovative model which explored the direct and indirect relationship between principal's instructional leadership (IL), collective teachers' efficacy (CTE), shared vision (SV) and teachers' intent to leave (ITL) (see Figure 1) through two different research populations: Arab and Jewish teachers in Israeli schools.
In this study, we assume that IL will predict CTE and SV among teachers, subsequently decreasing their intent to leave. Teachers who participate in the school process (a shared vision) and believe that the faculty as a whole can execute the courses of action needed to positively affect student achievements will feel as if they are a part of the school, thus decreasing their intent to leave.
We turn now to briefly discuss the constructs employed and their measures:
Principal's instructional leadership: Hallinger and Murphy’s (1986) conceptual framework proposes three dimensions for the IL construct defining the school’s mission, managing the instructional program, and promoting a positive school-learning climate.
A shared vision: SV refers to the extent to which members of an entity agree on a vision for the future, which may then form the basis for action (e.g., Ensley, Hmieleski, & Pearce, 2006). Leadership practices aimed at developing a shared vision help to inspire and motivate organizational members, giving them an overall sense of purpose (Leithwood, Leonard, & Sharratt 1999). Thus, we hypothesized that IL will positively predict SV.
Collective teachers' efficacy: CTE represents the teachers' perception in a specific school that the faculty as a whole can execute the courses of action needed to positively affect student achievements (Goddard, Goddard, Kim, & Miller 2015). Principals' IL supports the degree to which teachers work together to improve instruction and may contribute to school effectiveness by strengthening collective efficacy beliefs (Goddard et al., 2015). Thus, we hypothesized that IL will positively predict CTE.
Teacher's intent to leave: Teacher's ITL is a withdrawal behavior, which refers to a set of attitudes and behaviors adopted by employees when they stay at a job but for some reason decide to be less participative (Kaplan et al., 2009). Lopez (2018) identified a significant negative relationship between collective teacher efficacy and teacher's intent to leave. To our knowledge, there are no previous studies which explore the relationship between teachers' intent to leave and a shared vision.
Method
Participants and Procedures
One thousand seven hundred teachers from 130 elementary schools (30 Arab schools, 100 Jewish schools) were randomly selected from a school list on the Israeli educational system website; we ensured a random sampling minimum of 30% of the teaching staff at each school. Teachers completed the measures assessing IL, CTE, SV and ITL. Years in post of the principals and teachers as well as school size was noted.
Measures
Participating teachers completed questionnaires concerning the principals' IL (Hallinger & Murphy's (1986), CTE (Tschannen-Moran & Barr, 2004), SV (Anderson & West, 1998) and ITL (Shapira- Lishchinsky, 2012). We controlled for the effects of school principal' years in post and school size (i.e., number of teachers in each school), and teachers’ years of teaching.
Analysis
We conducted a multilevel structural equation modeling (ML-SEM), using Mplus 6.12 (Muthe´n & Muthe´n, 1998–2011) which combines path analysis with hierarchical data and can therefore accurately estimate the variable parameters and errors.
Results
Both of the hypothesized Jewish and Arab models showed a good model fit for the data. However, none of the relationships between the control variables and teacher's intent to leave or between principals’ tenure in their job and IL were significant (in the Arab and Jewish model), so these paths were omitted from the diagram (see Figure 2). As seen in Figure 2, in the Jewish model: principals' IL positively predicted both CTE and SV and both of them negatively predicted teacher's intent to leave. When we tested a mediating effect, both of these variables played a mediating role between IL and teacher's ITL. Meanwhile, in the Arab model, shared vision had no significant correlation with IL nor with teacher's ITL; IL positively predicted CTE, and CTE negatively predicted teachers' ITL. Concerning the mediating role, only CTE played this role between IL and teacher's intent to leave. One possible explanation of these findings is that Arab culture is still characterized as a collectivist culture which reflects on relationships between school principals and teachers and tends to be characterized with power distance which makes a shared vision irrelevant in its impact and therefore did not play as a mediating variable between principals' IL and teachers' ITL.



Significance
By exploring this topic, we can contribute to the growing interest in principals' practices for retaining high-quality teachers. Understanding the factors that contribute to teacher's intent to leave could help school principals and policymakers to retain effective teachers in today's schools. This study also encourages policymakers and school principals to lead changes that support collective teacher efficacy and a shared vision. Teachers empowered by their instructional school leaders enjoy their jobs, participate more, and are less likely to leave the profession. This study also contributes to the growing importance of comparing various ethnic and religious sectors nested within the same educational system. Our full-length paper includes extensive details of data collection, statistical analysis and a description of opportunities for utilizing this study's findings while discussing limitations and suggesting avenues for future research.

Authors