Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Our paper aims to investigate Argentina’s participation in PISA. Argentina has been participating in PISA since its first edition, in 2000, and has consistently occupying bottom positions in the PISA rankings in Science, Math and Reading, along most of the countries in Latin America.
PISA 2012 innovated in presenting its results in national and regional levels. Argentina’s capital, Buenos Aires (referred as Cidade Autónoma de Buenos Aires, or CABA, in PISA reports), has out-performed not only the country, but all Latin American participants, in the 2012 measurement. In 2015, Argentina participated again in PISA, but due to a sample issue, the results haven’t been published in the country level. CABA’s results, on the contrary, have been published.
This episode generated some fuzz in Argentina, fed by the media. Some say that the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) excluded Argentina from the PISA 2015 ranking (Bio 2016; Infobae 2016). There are also claims that Argentina showed improvement in 2015 compared to 2012’s results, but this happened because ‘Argentina had left out schools that had historically been part of the test’, meaning that the previous administration lacked ‘commitment with statistics’ (Bio 2016). In fact, there is no need to select the same schools for the PISA samples every time, but the sample should be representative of the Argentinian students’ population. Other media sources argue that students have been trained for the PISA test, and that the students’ ‘sensitization’ for PISA have been even stronger in CABA (Polack 2016). The motivation for such situation relies on different political interests and reactions towards OECD and PISA from current and past national administrations, as the government changed right after the PISA tests in 2015, and from opponent parties leading the government of Argentina and the government of CABA. The political turmoil increased the popularity of the topic in the national debate, whereas the government reputation was either supported or slandered, depending on the political colour of the media.
Our concern is that PISA seems to be used as a scapegoat in Argentinian politics. Following a Foucauldian perspective, we understand that all objects of knowledge are objects of power (Simons 2013). In the Argentina case, PISA has become a powerful instrument to legitimize (or delegitimize) political power. Our objectives are to identify the political discourses that sustain the use of PISA in relation to political power and to explore its political effects. In other words, we are interested to investigate the political possibilities offered by PISA in Argentina and the political opportunities such possibilities enable in the local context.
Globally, PISA portrays a neoliberal discourse in which ideas such as accountability, comparability and performativity are emphasized (Osborne & Gaebler 1993; Hood & Jackson 1991; Ball 2012). These dynamics permeate political decision-making processes in distinct geographical spaces as a world culture that diffuses general trends of education and politics (Meyer et al. 1997). Improving educational standards, competing for a high position in PISA ranking, and using comparability as a governance tool seem to be global manifestations of the world culture, whereas performing well in PISA grants legitimacy and status to countries, in the international level, and to governments, in the domestic level, by increasing soft power. As a result, nation-states seemed to be compelled by PISA to adopt particular policies, most of the time mainly directly associated with the rise of New Public Management ideas that sustain steering at a distance (Morgan 2018; Volante & Fazio 2018).
Rather than highlighting a ‘world culture’ discourse of governance through data, we emphasize the local adaptation of PISA in Argentinian governance, which suits the Argentinian demands and interests. We argue that instead of passively acquiescing to world culture Argentina’s decisions are based on contingent convergence, structural coupling and skillful recontextualisation, whereas ‘agents selectively appropriate, relocate, refocus and recombine’ (Sum 2009, p. 191) discourses to support their own arguments. Studies on policy transfer, policy borrowing and lending, transnational circulation, policy diffusion and adoption, among others, have shown the wide variety of grey zones existing between global mainstream discourses and decisions attached to governing practices (Phillips & Ochs 2004; Steiner-Khamsi 2010; Verger 2016; Addey & Sellar 2017; Fischman et al. 2018). Furthermore, the Argentinian appropriation of PISA in its domestic governance is an example of glocalization, in which there is interdependence between the global and the local: ‘global models instill agency into empowered locals, who in turn enact and thus reinforce such global scripts’ (Drori et al. 2014).
We analyze political discourses that refer to Argentina’s participation in PISA from international and domestic official documents and media. We employ qualitative content analysis to identify the discourses that show the use of PISA to legitimate (or delegitimate) political power. The analysis is based on secondary sources: (1) Previous literature on the PISA tests in Argentina; (2) Reports produced by the OECD/PISA for Argentina; (3) Documents of the Ministry of Education and educational measurement agencies from Argentina; (4) Argentinian and international media reports about PISA 2012 and PISA 2015.
Preliminary results indicate that evidence for policy together with national politics seem to be at the basis of the use of PISA in Argentina: PISA is being effectively used not only to legitimize educational policy reform agendas (Fischman et al. 2018) but also as a window of opportunity to re-orient national politics. In this sense, the paper considers the Argentinian case as an opportunity to provide a more nuanced understanding of the emerging paradoxes around nation’s political responses to PISA with focus on political sustainability.
References:
Addey, C.; Sellar, S. (2017) Why do countries participate in PISA? Understanding the role of international large-scale assessments in global education policy’’. In: Verger, A.; Novelli, M.; Altinyelken, H. K. (eds.) Global Education Policy and International Development: New Agendas, Issues and Policies. Bloomsbury Academic, 97-117.
Bio, D. (2016). Argentina Excluded From PISA Exam Results. TheBubble. Available at http://www.thebubble.com/argentina-excluded-from-pisa-exam-results/; retrieved on 23.Aug.2018.
Drori, G. S., Höllerer, M. A. and Walgenbach, P. (2014). The Glocalization of Organization and Management. Issues, Dimensions, and Themes. In: Drori, G. S.; Höllerer, M. A. and Walgenbach, P. (eds.) Global Themes and Local Variations in Organization and Management. Perspectives on Glocalization. New York: Routledge, 3-23.
Fischman, G.; Marcetti Topper, A.; Silova, I.; Goebel, H.; Holloway, J. (2018) Examining the influence of international large-scale assessments on national education policies. Journal of Education Policy. DOI: 10.1080/02680939.2018.1460493
Hood, C. and Jackson, M. (1991). Administrative argument. Aldershot: Dartmouth.
Infobae (2016). Papelón internacional: la Argentina fue excluida de las pruebas PISA. Available at https://www.infobae.com/sociedad/2016/12/05/papelon-internacional-la-argentina-fue-excluida-de-las-pruebas-pisa/; retrieved on 23.Aug.2018.
Meyer, J. W.; Boli, J.; Thomas, G. M.; Ramirez, F. O. (1997) World Society and the Nation-State. American Journal of Sociology 103(1), 144-81.
Morgan, C. (2018). Problematizing the Expansion of PISA’s Explanatory Power. In: Volante, L. (ed.) The PISA Effect on Global Educational Governance. NY & London: Routledge.
Osborne, D. and Gaebler, T. (1993). Reinventing government: how the entrepreneurial spirit is transforming the public sector. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
Phillips, M. and Ochs, K. (2004). Researching policy borrowing: Some methodological challenges in comparative education. British Educational Research Journal, (30)6, 773-784.
Polack, M.E. (2016). PISA 2015: admiten que los estudiantes fueron preparados. La Nacion. Available at https://www.lanacion.com.ar/1965258-pisa-2015-admiten-que-los-estudiantes-fueron-preparados; retrieved on 23.Aug.2018.
Simons, J. (2013). Foucault and the Political. London: Taylor and Francis.
Steiner-Khamsi, G. (2010). The Politics and Economics of Comparison. Comparative Education Review, 54(3), 323-342.
Sum, N-L. (2009). The Production of Hegemonic Policy Discourses: 'Competitiveness' as a Knowledge Brand and Its (Re-)Contextualizations. Critical Policy Studies 3(2), 184-203.
Verger, A. (2016). The Global Diffusion of Education Privatization: Unpacking and Theorizing Policy
Adoption. In: Mundy, K., Green, A., Lingard, B. and Verger, A. (eds.) The Handbook of Global Education Policy. London: Wiley.
Volante, L.; Fazio, X. (2018) PISA, Policy, and Global Educational Governance. In: Volante, L. (ed.) The PISA Effect on Global Educational Governance. NY & London: Routledge.
Helena Hinke Dobrochinski Candido, University of Helsinki
Felicitas Acosta, Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento