Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Introduction: In recent years, Bangladesh has dramatically succeeded in improving access to basic education and increasing primary school enrollment. Despite these successes, the lack of access to quality education remains a major challenge to students. Unavailability of supplementary teaching and learning materials, inadequate teaching methods, and poor infrastructure in primary schools has led to students falling behind as they fail to achieve satisfactory results, leading to grade repetition and/or dropout. The educational challenges have resulted in low literacy rates and have had wide-reaching effects on other aspects of society.
Method: The study was conducted using a repeated cross-sectional design; this methodology was utilized as it takes a snapshot of a given population at a specific time and, as such, is commonly used to measure pre and post test results of an intervention. The respondents were students of grade II and III in both schools where the intervention was implemented (intervention group) and schools that did not have the READ project (comparison group). Overall sample size was calculated while planning the baseline survey and same sampling strategy was followed for both baseline and endline. The Early Grade Reading Assessment (EGRA) tool was used for the study using tablet devices and KoBoToolbox in April 2018. statistical regression model was used to determine if there was a relationship between reading skills (letter knowledge, most used words, similar beginning sounds, rhyming words, reader, comprehension, fluency, accuracy) and intervention status. To assess the impact of the intervention on grade II and grade III children’s reading competencies, an evaluation was carried out in March-April 2018. It adopted a repeated cross sectional design, with a control group for comparison. The study was conducted in 6 regions of Bangladesh (Barishal, Cox’s Bazar, Dhaka, Jessore, Rangpur and Sylhet) among 765 grade II children and 768 grade III children. Results were compared to a baseline that was conducted in the same schools in June-July 2015. The duration of project implementation at the time of endline data collection was 2 years and 9 months.
Results: Over 90% of students at Intervention schools have mastered emergent literacy skills, such as, letter knowledge, frequent word recognition, similar beginning words and rhyming words. At the endline, second graders in READ schools recognized 93% of the Bangla letters, identified similar beginning and rhyming words with 91% accuracy, and read 94% of the frequent words. The average third grader at READ intervention schools identified 95% of the letters, 96% of the frequent words, 93% of beginning word sounds, and 95% of rhyming words. These results show that most students are acquiring the emergent literacy skills to become readers.
Over 90% grade II and grade III students of Intervention schools became reader (who could read minimum 5 words in 30 second) at the endline. Students in Intervention schools were more likely to be fluent readers than students in comparison schools. All students at Intervention schools showed greater improvement in comprehension (both listening and reading) than students in comparison schools, and the difference is statistically significant (p<0.05). Improvement of listening comprehension among non-readers in READ schools was from 0% to 73% for grade II and 0% to 66% for grade III. Significantly more READ school students could read with comprehension by endline, compared to comparison group.
There were no differences in achievement between students who attended preschool, students of different socioeconomic statuses or by gender. Studies have demonstrated that children who read with parents or other adults tend to have a richer vocabulary than children who do not read with parents/other adults. Results were similar for intervention and comparison groups as approximately 90% of all students reported of receiving help from family members at both baseline and endline.
There were no differences in achievement between students who attended preschool, students of different socioeconomic statuses or by gender. This may be an indication that previous government and donor-led initiatives to address these issues have helped reduce inequalities in these areas. Students at READ schools reported studying longer and were more likely to read with peers. Students at READ schools are more likely to borrow books from the library1 than their peers at schools without the intervention.
At endline, among all second grade students of Intervention schools, 68% could read with comprehension, compared to 37% students in comparison schools; it was 7% students from both groups in the baseline. For grade III, 75% READ school students could read with comprehension, (6% at baseline), in comparison to 37% of the non-READ school students (5% at baseline). Higher order thinking skills are not only critical for reading achievement, but they are also crucial to success in other academic subjects; these results indicate that the READ program may indirectly impact other educational outcomes in a student’s academic trajectory.
Recommendation and Conclusion: Conduct policy dialogues to discuss how to include fluency and comprehension benchmarks in national assessments. As fluency can be language-specific, holding policy dialogues and bench-marking workshops that include a range of policy and education stakeholders would be best to determine the benchmarks that would suit the Bangladeshi context and identify what types of educational materials for both students and teachers might support this initiative. Emphasizing the importance of fluency and comprehension at the policy level will reinforce efforts aimed at improving these reading skills at the school and classroom levels.
The endline study found that the program played an important role in improving reading outcomes for grade II and grade III students. More students became independent readers in the intervention schools. The study also found significant improvement in reading fluency and comprehension among intervention school students, compared to comparison group; these achievements significantly improved from baseline as well. However, the endline study indicates that there is a need to further improve students’ fluency, which is below the level suggested by global research, even after significant improvement. This presents an opportunity to make specific recommendations to further investigate and address the scopes of improvement in increasing reading fluency among primary level students.