Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Publication trends in Comparative Education: 1960 to 2015

Tue, April 16, 5:00 to 6:30pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific H

Proposal

The beliefs of originators of large-scale studies was summarized by Husén (1983) who wrote that the empirical results provided by the first IEA studies were useful as guides for policy making and for theoretical analysis, but not as a guide for establishing goals for education or society. He noted that the acceptability of empirical research in the 1950’s was regarded differently by different countries. Some, like Germany were not certain that empiricism could provide useful answers to policy questions; whereas others, as in the USA at the time, didn’t believe otherwise. Husén noted that the results of experiments in Sweden during the period of reform from selective to comprehensive schools could be used for arguments on both sides of the debate about the relative effectiveness of selective or comprehensive school organization.
Critical analysis of survey methods, of definitions of student knowledge, of the role of curriculum and teacher methods, of use of student time, and of cultural and historical differences between countries have been a topic of many publications. However, rather than stop the growth of these studies, their producers were challenged by the criticisms and sought methods to strengthen the methods of data collection and analysis (Bradburn & Gilford, 1990).
This presentation reports on an examination of whether large-scale studies have been used mainly for policy debates or more for scientific study by an analysis of trends in types of articles and books published in comparative education journals. The trends in publications demonstrated that hundreds of reports of large-scale research have been produced by the responsible data collection organizations and by governmental and international policy-analysis organizations. However, the dominant trend in the past 20 years has been a large increase in academic attention to small-scale as well as large-scale internationally comparative studies.
The observation of changes in publication patterns of the field of comparative education show evidence of recent expansion of data collection activities to many countries appears to have a momentum that is not likely to subside soon. The field of comparative education research will benefit from the increased number of researchers publishing research and commentary on international differences in educational practices. Likewise, the field of comparative education, by increasingly accumulating knowledge of different educational systems, will contribute to the development of improved empirical measurement methods, frameworks and theories of understanding cross national differences.

Author