Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
The classification of comparative education as discipline, field, or discourse has undergone many attempts to characterize the research generated over a 70-year period. In the 1950s, UNESCO’s Institute for Education recognised comparative education as a discipline, (see Edwards et al. 1973). At that time, the division of research was concentrated in four inward-looking themes and seven outward-seeking themes such as curricular goals (inward-looking) and impact of international development on national educational policy (outward-seeking themes).
Efforts to classify comparative education as a discipline for purposes of ‘scientific legitimacy' were eventually replaced by characterising it as a multidisciplinary field that examines education in cross-cultural contexts (Altbach 1991, p. 491). The content of the field was considered to be a part of area studies, social science, or development/planning studies (Hawkins & Rust 2001). Often, scholars have used colourful rhetorical postulations such as Nash’s variegated mosaic while others, argued for a ‘critical path’ analysis (King, 1975, p. 86), or for probing the assumptions of educational planners and decision makers (Adams 1990, p. 382).
My thesis is that comparative education research has often been approached incorrectly. Too often, researchers begin with preconceived notions of conclusions. Researchers should recognize the limits of the domain (Edwards 1970, p. 240). Some have observed that the training of comparative education researchers with cross-disciplinary backgrounds has created researchers who cannot compensate for a lack of depth in each discipline with breadth of insights from general observations" (Bereday 1967b, p 180). If comparative educators give their major scholarly allegiance to non-education fields---such as economics, sociology, anthropology, and history---then the area study will appear eclectic. The unifying notion of the field is the object of education and a generally comparative approach (Lawson 1975, p. 347). Systematic analysis and review are critical.
Thus, efforts to increase the explanatory power of data and its impact on educational policy-making and governance can be achieved by linking data from different assessments, by undertaking secondary analyses of data-sets and by making findings more accessible and useable for policy-makers and others (Sellar 2015, p. 772). Most of the critical reviews of comparative education literature underline the methodological weaknesses of the field by contrasting them with the higher degree of sophistication of other comparative social sciences. (Schriewer 1988, p. 27)
Virtually all comparative education studies exist with an epistemological stance in which social facts function as dependent or independent variables. The perceived values and effects of globalisation are often contested, classified as uneven, and value laden in research on education. Knowledge is not static. The pure, unadulterated truth is not an absolute but is a manifestation of social reality constructed at a particular time and place. Yet, in our field, there is an increasing need to demonstrate that variables reflect greater veracity, Imprecise channels of communication require due diligence in scrutinizing and cleaning' of data. The integrity of the research must meet explicit standards in the criteria for determining the admissibility of data and applying appropriate measurements to identify 'truths'. The quality and reliability of appropriate measuring instruments must reflect consistent results when the characteristics being measured have not changed.