Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

From Southern Brazil to Southern Spain: narratives of professional development from teachers of English as an Additional Language

Mon, April 15, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific O

Proposal

The new millennium has brought teacher development back to the limelight of the debate regarding education enhancement, after the theme had remained in relative ostracism for a long time (Nóvoa, 2009). A number of recent productions grounded in different ontological and epistemological perspectives and produced in different parts of the globe have discussed teacher development -- both research reports (e.g. Nóvoa, 1995; 2009; Villegas-Reimers, 2003; Saviani, 2009) and documents produced by international agencies (e.g. AEE, 2014; EU, 2013; OCDE, 2006).

By the same token, the development of additional language (AL) teachers has also received a attention, both also in the form of international documents (e.g. Edge & Mann, 2013; Judd, Tan, & Walberg, 2001) and in the form of research reports. For this paper, research reports that attempt to understand the development of AL teachers as a process that occurs in/through social practice (Costa, 2013; Merril, 2016; Kirsch, 2017), chiefly in communities of teachers, are of special interest.

Costa (2013) describes the professional development of teachers of Portuguese as an AL in a binational center of a Latin American country though the use of ethnographic methods, focusing on everyday interactions among teachers and how these interactions stimulate professional learning for said teachers. Merril (2016) describes the experiences of teacher assistants (TA) of a range of different AL in a large research university in US midwest in their trajectory as TAs at the university, which usually happens during grad school. The researcher focuses on the interactions on which these TAs engage on in their departments, with other TAs or career professors from the university, and how such interactions help enhance professional knowledge. For that, the author uses questionnaires and semi-structured interviews. Kirsch (2017) describes the practices of teacher development of teachers of English as an AL within a community of teachers that stems from a governmental program at a large university in the south of Brazil. The researcher focuses on the diverse the practices of teacher professional that happen within the scope of the program at the university, attempting to reconstruct participants’ experiences through participant observation and semi-structured interviews.

The three investigations described above have three things in common: (1) they attempt to understand teacher development as a process that happens both in the realm of technical rationality (scientific, academic and professional knowledge) and in the realm of practical knowledge (know-how, handmanship, etc.); (2) they understand that teacher development efforts should offer teachers the chance to construct knowledge by integrating such technical and practical realms in professional situations that emerge from teaching practice in everyday life (including interactions with students, peers and supervisors/coordinators); (3) they commit to the production of knowledge that is situated and concerned with the perspective and the interpretations of the participants.

The present research is in continuum with said investigation reports, but it aims at advancing the discussion in different ways. First, it adopts biographic and narrative investigation as a research method. According to Rivas Flores (2009), the adoption of biographic and narrative methods: (1) recovers el value of subjectivity; (2) sees reality as a collective construction; and (3) understands reality as a social and historical, and, thus, contingent.

It is also important to note that the three studies briefly described above focus on relatively homogeneous communities: a binational center, a large university in US midwest and a government program in a large Brazilian university. That is to say, they are centered solely on local questions at the communities investigated. This research investigates the practices of initial teacher education of teachers of EAL in two groups: students in the end of their teacher certification or recent graduates of EAL teaching in a large university in the south of Brazil and in the south of Spain. Thus, differently from the previous studies addressed here, this paper inserted in a comparative paradigm (Shaner, Nagatomo, y Yasuo, 1989).

The first stage of investigation consisted of narrative interviews with EAL teachers recently graduated or about to graduate from undergrad level in a large university in the south of Brazil. After the interviews were done, they were transcribed orthographically and analyzed. In the analysis, we identified the main themes relating to teacher development. Afterwards, the themes were refined and discussed with the participants and adjusted according to their interpretations.

The second stage of the investigation was carried out in a similar manner, however this time with EAL teachers recently graduated or about to graduate from undergrad level in a large university in the south of Spain. The methodological and analytical procedures were the same the same as in stage one.

The analysis will consist of a comparison of the main themes identified so as to identify common themes that both groups of teachers consider important to their professional development both inside and outside school. Through the analysis, we will be able to elucidate the practice of teachers development that are central for both groups of participants. In a moment when, in Brazil and elsewhere, we are questioning the practices of teacher development to prepare future teachers, an investigation such as this has the potential to reveal the practices that in both institution proved more successful with the teachers they graduate.

In short, in this presentation, we will compare the practices of teacher development among EAL teachers of both universities, through a narrative and autobiographical approach.

Authors