Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Learning is the foundation of sustainable development in the 21st century, and numerous studies have emphasized the centrality of teacher learning as part of the efforts to improve student learning. Contemporary education reforms around the world, therefore, have focused on teachers’ professional development (PD). PD can improve teaching practice by enhancing teacher knowledge and skills, and better teaching affects student learning outcomes. For instance, teachers who participate in PD learn a variety of contents which can be used to advance their teaching quality, such as effective teaching methods, curricular changes, new theories of student learning, and innovative technologies and tools. A type of PD is also crucial. PD has various types of activities including workshops, in-service training, informal dialogue among teachers to improve teaching, mentoring and peer observation and so on. With these PD contents and activities, teachers can improve teaching practice and student learning.
Among many student outcomes, students’ academic achievement has given disproportionate attention from the previous studies on the effect of teachers’ PD on student outcomes (Hill, Beisiegel, & Jacob, 2013; Yoon et al., 2007). However, it is equally important to examine the relationship between teachers’ PD and other student outcomes such as students’ collaborative problem solving skills. Collaborative problem solving skills are a fundamental competency to effectively engage in solving a problem by sharing the understanding, knowledge, skills, and efforts to reach a solution. Students, who are confronted with complex challenges of today’s world, need to improve their collaborative-problem solving competency. For example, job markets demand a high level of social skills including collaborative skills beyond traditional cognitive skills such as mathematics (Deming, 2017). Moreover, almost every human interacts with other individuals not only in the workplace but also in daily lives, so collaboration skills are necessary to facilitate such interactions.
Therefore, this proposed study aims to empirically examine the relationship between teachers’ participation in various PD activities and students’ collaborative problem solving skills. Specifically, this study addresses three research questions: 1) Is the participation of teachers in PD related to collaborative problem solving skills of students? 2) If so, what types of PD are related to collaborative problem solving scores of students? 3) Does the relationship between teachers’ PD and students’ collaborative problem solving scores differ by students and their backgrounds such as academic achievement and socio-economic status (SES)?
To answer these questions, this study employed multilevel regression using data from the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) of 2015. Multilevel regression modeling can consider that students are nested within higher-level groups such as schools and countries. The PISA data also provides a variety of information on teachers’ participation in different types of PD activities, students’ collaborative problem solving scores, and school and family backgrounds. This study analyzed the data from a total of 102,216 students from 22 OECD countries, excluding the missing responses. The key independent variable is the participation of teachers in PD activities. PISA asked school principals whether their school offers the following in-house PD activities or not: (a) The teachers in our school cooperate by exchanging ideas or material when teaching specific units or 4 series of lessons; (b) Our school invites specialists to conduct in-service training for teachers; (c) Our school organizes in-service workshops which deal with specific issues that our school faces’ and (d) Our school organizes in-service workshops for specific groups.
The preliminary analysis of this study showed that the average of the teachers’ participation in the four PD activities was positively associated with the students’ collaborative problem solving scores. Concerning the type of PD, ‘organizing in-service workshops for specific issues that school faces’ and ‘organizing workshops for specific groups of teachers’ were positively associated with the students’ collaborative problem solving capacity. By contrast, ‘cooperation by exchanging ideas or teaching material’ and ‘inviting specialists to train teachers’ were not significantly related to the students’ collaborative problem solving skills. The preliminary analysis also found that students with high academic achievement and students from high SES family took advantages from teachers’ PD for specific groups of teachers, whereas underperforming students and students from lower SES benefited more from teachers’ PD for the specific issues.
Even though this study is not able to make clear causal inferences without controlling for longitudinal information, the preliminary results of this study provide meaningful empirical evidence. The PD activities targeted for specific teacher groups or development program on specific issues that school faces are positively related to students’ collaborative problem solving skill. These types of PD would be more effective because the PD for the specific issues and groups are based on their school contexts. In other words, focusing on a specific problem that their school should solve and targeting a particular group such as novice teachers could successfully affect students’ collaborative problem solving. Also, each of the two types of PD is associated with an increase in collaborative problem solving skills of different student groups. This result indicates that effective use of different types of PD can serve diverse learners but at the same time leaves an implication that some PD might benefit a particular group of students. Still, future research should consider the quality of PD, such as a frequency, intensity, and duration, beyond the participation and types of PD. The final paper will discuss in depth about the policy implications of the findings, limitations of this study, and directions for future research.
// End (829 out of 1,000-words limit)
Hansol Woo, Penn State University
Ji-hye Kim, Penn State University
Jee Bin Ahn, Penn State University