Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Although traditional credentials and foundational skills continue to be important, policymakers are increasingly concerned about soft skills and argue that educators should focus on teaching students “soft” or transferrable skills so that they can be successful in the 21st century knowledge economy (OECD, 2012). Previous research largely based on U.S. data suggests that social skills have become more important in the labor market over the past 20 years (Deming, 2017). This is partly attributable to the fact that the services sector has an increasing share of the economy and requires strong social skills. Less known is how cognitive and soft skills are related to labor market outcomes across countries with varying levels of development and different composition of economic sectors.
This paper examines relationships among cognitive skills, soft skills (focusing on attitudes towards learning new things), and occupational outcomes across four countries with varying levels of income and distinct composition of economic sectors. Among them, Germany and US are in the high-income group, Colombia being upper-middle income, and Vietnam is in the lower-middle income group. The services sector occupies 73.6% of employment in the US, 58.7% in Germany, 61.2% in Colombia, and 30.4% in Vietnam.
To analyze these relationships across four countries, data are drawn from two sources: (1) The Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies (PIAAC) from the OECD (for Germany and the US); and (2) the Skills Towards Employability and Productivity (STEP) by the World Bank (for Colombia and Vietnam). Both datasets contain direct measures of cognitive skills in the domain of literacy, and rich background information, including a wide range of self-reported indicators which could be used as proxies for some aspects of skills. The literacy assessments in the two surveys were designed and operationalized intentionally to be comparable. A question regarding “like learning new things” is asked in both surveys: I_Q04d in PIAAC, and m6a_q0111 in STEP. Both items use Likert scales and are standardized to be comparable across the two surveys. This question corresponds to “openness to experience” dimension of the widely used Big Five model of personal traits.
Two types of labor market outcomes are analyzed: logged wages and an indicator variable that records whether workers were unemployed and not enrolled in education or training for at least a twelve-month period. Regression models also include control variables for gender, age, and work experience.
Preliminary results suggest that despite the differences in income levels and economic sector composition, there is a relatively consistent pattern across four countries. Unlike schooling, attitudes towards learning new things are not statistically significantly related to earnings. However, it has a statistically significant relationship with whether the respondents are employed or in training programs. These findings have important policy implications for school and vocational training programs in terms of curricula, whether the combination of development modules of cognitive and soft skills would play distinctive roles, depending on the immediate policy objective – improving job quality or increasing higher labor market participation.