Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Partner Organizations
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
How is the topic relevant to comparative and international education, sustainability, or a SIG?
GirlsRead! Zambia is an empowerment-based education project that uses e-reader technology, girls’ groups, and community engagement to improve girls’ literacy and agency. As part of the DREAMS Innovation Challenge, GirlsRead! is grounded in evidence that suggests that female education, particularly secondary school, decreases HIV risk. A collaboration between Population Council, Worldreader, and Forum for African Women Educationalists of Zambia (FAWEZA), GirlsRead! thus draws on multiple disciplines – education, public health, and gender – in both its program design and evaluation.
The program was implemented with Grade 7 girls in three sites in Zambia, combining 1) safe spaces for girls where mentors facilitate an empowerment-based life skills curriculum; 2) e-readers with engaging content, primarily written by African authors, that girls keep for the duration of the program; and 3) community engagement to bolster learning outcomes, promote gender equality, and reduce the likelihood that girls will leave school early. The project was evaluated using a three-arm cluster randomized controlled trial (RCT) that assesses learning outcomes, reading habits, numeracy, views on gender norms, and agency.
The GirlsRead! project combined effective community programming and an ICT intervention (e-readers) with the aim of improving education outcomes. Our presentation will showcase results – both feasibility and impact - from the project as well as sustainability in the form of cost analysis and projections for greater adoption throughout the region. Due to the innovative nature of the tech intervention, we propose to include this in the ICT4D SIG.
What is the need or the problem that the program or intervention tries to address?
While school enrollment in sub-Saharan Africa has made significant strides, quality has suffered. For example, in 2002, only about 50% of Zambian girls who did not continue to secondary school but completed primary education could read a simple sentence. By 2013, this proportion had deteriorated slightly (DHS). Indeed, among 15 countries making up the Southern and Eastern Africa Consortium for Monitoring Educational Quality, Zambian Grade 6 students scored the lowest on reading, with over two-thirds reading below a minimally acceptable level. One reason for these poor statistics is the chronic lack of books.
What advice do you offer or do you seek at CIES, and how can it address similar challenges elsewhere?
We hope to share results of our intervention with other organizations interested in developing forward-thinking approaches to girls’ education that engage ICT. While our project was tailored to the Zambian context, we believe the lessons learned and interventions are transferable across geographies.
What would you have done differently, knowing what you know now about the project or program?
With a longer timeframe and additional funding, we would have tested GirlsRead! for longer as the intervention itself was comprised of just 19 sessions over about 6 months. We also would have included younger learners to determine if the effect of exposure to the e-reader is greater among those who are younger. These adjustments may or may not improve outcomes, but they are important implementation questions.
What was the impact of the project on the problem it targeted? How was the project’s impact assessed?
The feasibility of GirlsRead! was assessed with careful monitoring and its impact evaluated with a three-arm RCT. The evaluation design included baseline and endline surveys and literacy assessments. In each district – Lusaka, Chingola, and Ndola - schools were ranked by the proportion of girls aged 15+ — i.e., a higher proportion below grade for age — to reach more vulnerable girls. Schools with the highest proportion were selected. Selected schools (N=36) were randomly assigned within each district to one of three arms.
• Arm A: community engagement activities, girls’ groups and e-readers
• Arm B: community engagement activities and girls’ groups
• Arm C: no (delayed) activities
To equalize exposure, girls in Arm B had study and homework time instead of e-reader time. Each
intervention school (Arms A and B) had two girls’ groups for a total of 48 groups with approximately 16 girls per group for a target sample of 1152.
Feasibility was demonstrated with only about 2.4% of e-readers lost, stolen, or broken.
We tested literacy using the UWEZO assessment, a simple English diagnostic of reading foundational skills through grade two, developed by the People’s Action for Learning Network in East Africa. We calculated 3 outcomes: (Baseline percentages of girls passing are in parentheses):
1. Passed paragraph: respondent could read aloud letters, simple words, a paragraph containing 3 simple sentences and 20-22 words and make 2 or fewer mistakes (52.7%).
2. Passed story: respondent could do all components in “#1” plus could read a two paragraph 12 sentence story out loud and make 4 or fewer mistakes (44.3%).
3. Passed story questions: respondent could do all components in “#2” plus could answer 2 questions correctly about the story (38.5%).
Preliminary results show a significant impact both in intent to treat (ITT) analyses – which includes all girls enrolled, regardless of whether or how much they participated - and treatment on the treated (TOT) analyses. For the ITT results, compared to the control arm, passing the story was 4.6 percentage points higher (p=.089) in the e-reader arm and passing the two questions about the story was 6.4 percentage points higher (p=.016) in the e-reader arm. Among girls who attended 16+ sessions (out of 19), these two literacy benchmarks at endline were 8 (p<0.1) and 11 (p<0.01) percentage points higher in the e-reader arm than in the control; among girls who attended 18+ sessions, the difference was 16 (p<0.05) and 22 (p<0.01) percentage points higher. Scores for girls in the girls’ groups only arm, who did not have exposure to e-readers, were not significantly different from the control arm. We are currently analyzing effects of the intervention on other outcomes such as girls’ agency and will report these findings as well. The potential for such improvements in girls’ education to affect longer term indicators, including increased civic participation, improved health outcomes, and reduced HIV infection will also be discussed.
Barbara Mensch, Population Council
Nicole Haberland, Population Council
Michael Mbizvo, Population Council
Rachel Heavner, Worldreader
Natalie Jackson, Population Council
Nachela Chelwa, Population Council
Pamela Nyirenda, Population Council
Erica Soler-Hampejsek, Consultant
Erica Chuang, Population Council
Laura Ross Perry, Worldreader
Jean Digitale, Consultant
Lisa Polen, Population Council