Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Traveling Professional Development Model: Sustainability and Adaptation of Lesson Study in a U.S. Context

Mon, April 15, 8:00 to 9:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific O

Proposal

Study Objective

Lesson study that originates in Japan has spread to many countries around the globe (Lewis & Lee, 2018) since it was introduced as a system that supports Japanese teachers’ practice of high quality instruction in Teaching Gap, an influential book based on the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) (Stigler & Hiebert, 1999). Reflecting this trend, the number of countries represented among presenters at the World Association of Lesson Studies (WALS) conference has grown from 13 in 2007 to 35 in 2017, indicating the emergence of lesson study as a global model of teacher professional development.
Despite the popularity of lesson study, how lesson study has been adapted and sustained over time in a new cultural and organizational context is not yet fully understood. Furthermore, few studies examined the variation in adaptation within a region to examine how it may explain sustainability of lesson study. Considering the unique Japanese contexts regarding teachers’ work structure and responsibilities as well as the level of support they receive for engaging in lesson study as an institutionalized practice, it is important to examine how lesson study is adapted to fit within the new context and sustained over time to benefit the teachers.
This study focused on a context of Florida, USA where lesson study was introduced by the state department of education as an innovative professional development model in 2011. Based on a mix-method study of a longitudinal survey of 34 school district professional development directors and interviews of directors in 10 school districts, we addressed the following question: How do the districts that sustained lesson study differ from the districts that phased out lesson study in their approach to adapt lesson study?

Background

In lesson study, a group of teachers engage in four stages of: 1) studying the curriculum and student understanding in a chosen topic—a topic their students struggle with—and setting a student learning goal, 2) developing a research lesson that anticipates student responses and learning, 3) teaching the research lesson in a classroom of one group member while others gather data on student responses and thinking processes, and 4) discussing the effectiveness of the lesson in promoting student learning (Lewis & Hurd, 2011).
Previous studies on lesson study tend to emphasize the challenges for implementing lesson study due to cultural differences (Ebaegin & Stephen, 2013; Groves et al., 2016; Lim et al., 2011). However, research on scalability and sustainability of a reform initiative sees that adaptation of an innovation is a natural part of scaling up across diverse contexts with different resources and points to the importance of ownership and capacity building (Coburn 2003; Dede et al. 2005; McLaughlin and Mitra 2001). Based on this perspective, we examined how the districts that sustained lesson study adapted it compared to the districts that decreased or stopped practicing lesson study.

Methods

We conducted a statewide longitudinal survey of professional development directors who are in charge of promoting lesson study in all 68 regular school districts in Florida in 2014, 2015, and 2016. A total of 45 districts participated in all three waves of surveys with a response rate of 66%. From these districts, we chose only the districts that sustained lesson study (12 sustaining districts) and the districts that either decreased or stopped practicing lesson study (22 phasing-out districts) since 2014. The remaining districts have either never practiced lesson study or have not engaged in lesson study until later.
We interviewed professional development directors of 4 sustaining districts and 6 phasing-out districts and asked them about five topics: (1) influence of RTTT program and district policies on lesson study, (2) district approaches to lesson study, (3) funding support, (4) sustainability and changes, and (5) coherence and integration of lesson study.

Results and Conclusion

The interviews revealed that the district leaders in all 10 districts expressed their commitment to promote lesson study as they saw its benefits for teachers. In order to make it feasible for their own districts, all of them adapted the model. However, the nature of adaption was different between sustaining districts and phasing-out districts.
Sustaining districts adapted lesson study to fit within the instructional system with changing priorities and leadership. They saw lesson study as a flexible process that can be aligned with other core elements in the instructional system. Integrating lesson study into stable core elements and supporting school and teacher ownership of the process allowed the districts to sustain lesson study over time. In District A, for example, lesson study was embedded into professional learning communities that are well established in the district. In this district, lesson study is also part of teacher evaluation and teacher groups earn points by sharing their learning to the entire faculty and discussing lesson study packets in the end-of-year conference with the principal.
On the other hand, Phasing-out districts saw lesson study as a rigorous and powerful PD model and they adapted lesson study by developing a specific approach with protocols and templates in order to ensure the fidelity of implementation. These districts involved district-level facilitators in every lesson study process because they were concerned that the fidelity of lesson study may be compromised by teachers. In District B, for example, they developed a 2-day model of lesson study with templates for norm setting, lesson plan, and debriefing protocol, and allowed only the district-level specialists to facilitate lesson study in order to maintain the quality. However, the lack of district capacity to drive the lesson study process in every school eventually led to a decreased level of lesson study practice.
The study revealed that adaptation of lesson study to integrate into the core instructional system and supporting school and teacher ownership of lesson study allowed the districts to sustain lesson study without federal funding. This finding supports the importance of carefully considering the contexts for adaptation and supporting school and teacher ownership for an international model to be successfully sustained and benefit teachers and students.

Authors