Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Korean Student Activism against State-issued History Textbooks

Tue, April 16, 5:00 to 6:30pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific M

Proposal

This research explores how Korean students resisted against the government’s plan to introduce state-issued history textbooks. Student activism sparked around the country after former Korean president Park Geun-hye’s government announced plans to replace all privately published history textbooks in middle and high schools to a single state-issued one in 2015. Focusing on how youth activists opposed the enforcement of a singular narrative of history in school curriculum, this study examines how the government attempted to reproduce structures of power by controlling the knowledge taught in schools and how students exhibit agency in speaking up about the curriculum they would be taught. Furthermore, this paper documents how student activists created alternative knowledge and discourses about curriculum, education, and power. Students demonstrated agency in resisting perpetuation of singular historical narratives and creating discourses of learning as a process built through multiple perspectives, understandings, and knowledge.

Background
In 2015, the Korean government stated that it will create and distribute a single state-issued history textbook to be used in all middle and high schools throughout the country by March 2017, replacing the previous system in which schools could choose from a range of privately published textbooks (Truth Commission, 2018). The policy, which aimed to increase patriotism by teaching students the ‘right’ history, came into place after former President Park Geun-hye mentioned that students were being tainted by ‘left-leaning’ history textbooks (Choe, 2015; Choe, 2017). However, scholars pointed out that this rewriting of history glorifies certain historical incidents such as the dictatorship of Park’s father, Park Chung-hee, increases nationalistic portrayals of history, and precludes students from understanding history through multiple perspectives by reinforcing a singular historical narrative (Bang, 2015; Choi, 2016; Kang and Baek, 2016).
The policy encountered huge opposition from scholars, students, history professors, teachers, and various civil society groups (Evans, 2015; Kang and Baek, 2016). Students took to the streets in protest and various groups issued statements condemning the introduction of state-issued history textbooks. Student activism peaked during fall 2015 as the government publicized its plan to issue a singular history textbook on October 12th, 2015 and finalized it as official policy on November 3rd, 2015 (Kang and Baek, 2016). The policy came to a halt when former President Park was impeached in March 2017 and was officially abolished in May 2017 under the new South Korean president, Moon Jae-in (Choe, 2017).

Theoretical framework
I draw from critical pedagogy framework, which argues that education renders students as passive subjects and sheds lights on other ways of educating that disrupt power structures, to situate my study within broader conversations on the reproduction of dominant knowledge in educational systems and youth activists’ contestation of such knowledge. Critical pedagogy scholars argue that educational systems have been shaped to benefit the oppressors (Banks, 1993; Freire 1970; Shor, 1992). School curriculum and modes of instruction, for example, perpetuate power hierarchies by prioritizing knowledge of white, Western privileged class and rendering students as passive receivers of knowledge deposited onto them (Banks, 1993; Freire, 1970).
Critical pedagogy scholars have reimagined ways of educating that break away from oppression. Freire advocates for ‘problem-posing education’, which empowers people to develop a critical consciousness of their lived realities and intervene in the status quo (Freire, 1970). In doing so, students understand the world not as static but rather as a process of transformation (Freire, 1970). Social movements and critical spaces have also been incubators of critical pedagogy (Bajaj, 2015; Jaramillo and Carreon, 2014; Tarlau, 2014). Drawing from Tarlau’s (2014) understanding of social movements as pedagogical spaces, I examine student activism a site of critical pedagogy where students learn to critically examine the status quo, produce alternative knowledge and discourses, and transform the society.

Methodology
This study uses qualitative research methodology to shed light on the lived experiences of student activists as framed and recounted by themselves (Creswell, 2014; Esposito, 2011). This approach was crucial as I aimed to center the voices of youth activists as counter-narratives to dominant discourses (Delgado, 1989).
I conducted semi-structured interviews with 7 Korean student activists on August and September of 2018, which lasted between one to three hours. Participants were active in various activist groups formed in opposition to the government’s plan to reinforce state-issued history textbooks. Five of the activists were attending universities during their involvement in the activism, one was in graduate school, and one was a high school student. Among the six students who were receiving higher education, three were majoring in history and three were majoring in a similar subject, such as archaeology, art history, and history education.
I employed document analysis to gain insights on the alternative knowledge and discourses they created and publicized to resist the government’s attempts to take control of knowledge taught in the educational system. The documents I analyzed include press statements and declarations issued by student activist groups, news articles, a petition sent to the United Nations by an activist group, and a report issued in 2018 by Truth Commission for the Investigation of the Creation of State-issued History Textbook. I also studied daejabos, which are statements printed out or hand-written in large pieces of paper expressing opinions of the writer. A popular form of student activism and dissent in South Korea, daejabo was used by student movements since the late 1900s to spread political knowledge and expose injustices in universities and the country (Lee, 2002). Analyzing these statements of dissent helped me understand the knowledge, discourses, and resistance that student activists produced.

Implications
While state-issued history textbooks were abolished after the impeachment of former President Park, student activism against the textbooks have important implications for scholarship exploring the intersections of knowledge, power, and education. Student activists resisted the reproduction of singular historical knowledge written in the interests of existing power and produced alternative knowledge and discourses that highlighted education as learning gained from critically analyzing knowledge through multiple perspectives. This paper has further implications for future study on the construction of nationalism through curriculum and student-led movements on educational issues.

Author