Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Teaching for Social Justice in ESD programs: a case-study from Egypt

Wed, April 17, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview B

Proposal

To contribute to the global conversation regarding the place of Education for Sustainable Development (ESD) and the concept of sustainability in curricula globally, this paper attempts to elucidate the context of Egypt illustrating a case study of a developmental project that introduced ESD into the official school curricula. Years after the Egyptian revolution, several political challenges remain, accompanied with social and economic inequalities and problems such as inequitable distribution of wealth, unemployment amongst youth, corruption, and low levels of political participation (UNDP, 2012; Sewilam, et al., 2015). Vision 2030 was developed by Egypt’s Ministry of Planning and Administrative Reform in 2015 providing a roadmap for development that is inclusive of economic, environmental and social dimensions; including social justice, health, education, training and culture (World Bank, 2017), where ‘education’ was considered as one of the main tools for social transformation, aiming for improvement of quality of education, expanding access and improving learning outcomes across various regions.
In Egypt’s Strategic Plan of Pre-university Education (2014) several indicators of success were announced for the end of the year 2016/2017, including developing new curricula for sciences, mathematics and languages. Despite the plan being cognisant of the challenges to educational reform, such as the centralised nature of decision making and curriculum development, however a problematic policy is “adopting effective non cultural oriented international curricula like math, science, languages and geography” (Egypt’s Strategic Plan of Pre-university Education, 2014, p. 54). This policy implies that curricula of certain disciplines have the mere goal of gaining technical knowledge, and could be simply adopted from international sources, with no local contextualisation. This form of instrumentalist literacy focusing on “a banking approach and professional specialisation prevents the development of critical thinking that enables one to read the world critically and to understand the reasons and linkages behind the facts” (Macedo, 1993, p. 16) thus hinders the possibility of students’ critical civic engagement in response to critical consciousness of society’s problems.
Teachers must help students to “recognise, understand and critique current social inequalities”, in addition to encouraging academic excellence and cultural competence Ladson-Billings,1995, p. 476). However, at a time of centralised national curricula, and national testing which are used to hold schools accountable for students’ achievement, establish bench marks that allow parents to evaluate schools, and rank students against rigid fixed norms (Apple, 1993), emphasis on accountability can disempower teachers and inhibit their capability to address locally relevant concerns.
Educamp III; a European commission funded project, under the directorship of Dr. Hani Sewilam at the American Cairo in Egypt (AUC), aims to integrate (ESD) into formal education through its inclusion in the Egyptian curricula through various principles, two of which are teacher training and developing ESD resource kits which includes lesson plans that could be integrated into the current Ministry of Education (MOE)’s national curricula. ESD as explained by Cars & West (2015), includes three overlapping spheres; ecology, economy and society; which integrates concerns such as human rights, human security and gender equity. One of the themes included in Educamp III kits is the “society” which aims to expose students to inequalities in their local and global contexts and empower them to act upon their realities. This is an important aspect of ESD since “developing critical and creative thinkers who feel empowered to act as responsible citizens is a key to ESD” (Sewilam, et al., 2015, p. 224).
In this case-study type reflecting on one practitioner’s particular experience in the classroom ( Ellozy & Mostafa, 2010; Harrell 2011) and based on my involvement in this project, as a curriculum design, teachers trainer and mentor- where I delivered several lessons in the classroom, in this paper I attempt to document and critically self-reflect on various aspects of this project, particularly on the possible integration of social justice in ESD curricula as well as in Egypt’s official curricula highlighting possibilities and challenges. I do this with the ultimate aim of helping Egyptian ESD curricula become oriented on social aspects, just as environmental and economic aspects. Also to explain the space provided for teachers’ agency in Egyptian centralized, official curricula.
Although centralised curriculum is considered as a contributor to the compression of critical space in Education (as explained by Gandin, 2007; Hill, 2004 in McCarthy et al. (2009), teachers do have a critical role as curriculum developers where they could respond to curricular standards by ‘embracing’, ‘reframing’ or ‘resisting’ the impact of such curricular standards (Dover et al., 2016). In order to build an effective national curriculum, Apple (1993) recommends developing “new social and intellectual tissue” through the alignment of content and pedagogy of teacher education with that of the curriculum.
I explore: what are the possibilities to integrating ‘teaching for social justice’ in centralised official curricula, and what are the subsequent challenges? To what extent do teachers have agency to develop similar lesson plans (to that provided by the project) that are contextually relevant and address emerging social issues, after being trained and mentored throughout the follow- up visits phase conducted by trainers (who are the curriculum designers themselves). Topics such as tolerance, cultural diversity, community engagement, refugees, activism, democracy, human rights, gender issues and global citizenship that are integrated in the official standardised G1-9 MOE’s curricula through various subject areas are showcased in this paper.

Authors