Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Right to education policies and/as the spatial production of surplus populations

Wed, April 17, 8:00 to 11:30am, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Pacific Concourse (Level -1), Pacific N

Proposal

India is home both to the largest primary school system in the world as well as the largest child labor population. In response to the dilemma and in line with global policy frameworks on human capital and human rights, the Indian state has doubled down on the ‘right to education’ as the means of “combating” child labor. For instance, in Kanchipuram, a longstanding weaving center in Tamil Nadu, the state and its transnational partners have, since the turn of the millennium, “rescued and rehabilitated” working children by moving them out of their loom-based apprenticeships and into the formal educational spaces of government school classrooms. Drawing on over two years of ethnographic research in India, primarily sited in Kanchipuram’s weaving communities among cohorts of “rescued” child workers, but that also sought to study “up” from Kanchipuram’s transitional educational centers and neighborhoods schools to federal policy-making spaces constituted by national, multilateral and transnational statist and non-governmental agencies and actors, I consider how rights-based educational policies unfolded in ways – in spaces – that, in effect, rendered child workers’ learning and livelihood trajectories less safe and more precarious.
By attending to ‘space’ as an analytic – a response to the policy construction of school-spaces in opposition to work-spaces as, for instance, in the rhetoric of rescue from “exploitation to education” – I reflect on the spatializing effects of educational policy (see Ferguson & Gupta 2004), including who is – which populations are – enclosed within such spaces. How are these spaces imagined; especially in terms of the rights, relations and pathways that constitute them? And how are they experienced; especially in terms of the bodily disciplines, routines and bounds that make them visible?
Such a spatial analysis of right-to-education classrooms in Kanchipuram’s weavers’ neighborhoods reveals, in the first instance, that the classroom-space, as marked by physical as well as normative bounds, was a feminized space experienced as purdah in opposition to street/exterior-spaces rather as a protected space opposed to work-spaces. For boys, on the other hand, to perform an emerging masculinity necessitated an exit – an “escape” – from the classroom space. Another way to read the classroom space is to see it as a vacated space – vacated by fee-paying, (relatively) socially-advantaged groups, but also boys, spatially unfettered by social norms.
A third reading requires attention to the classroom space as shaped and distended by expectations of the future, whether hopeful, fearful or aspirational. A rather more phenomenological rather than Foucauldian analysis, perhaps, the considerations of the labor market as a horizon within which the classroom is contoured and inhabited reveals how the classroom also serves to produce its constituent populations as an underclass – as surplus populations (Li 2009; Davis 2006) who are not only to be managed – as a Foucauldian institutional analysis makes evident – but also populations abandoned and “let die” in rather more direct and material terms.

Author