Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The politicized experiences of women engineering faculty in Puerto Rico

Mon, April 15, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview B

Proposal

Introduction

The experiences of female faculty in universities provide education researchers with insight about the societies in which those institutions are located. In the case of Puerto Rico, the island-wide University of Puerto Rico (UPR) system is a microcosm of the politics of this commonwealth territory and its tenuous relationship with the United States. Enrolling nearly 60,000 students across its 11 campuses, UPR is the only public university system on the island (College Board, 2018).

In 2015, women obtained only 38% of Bachelor’s and 37% of Master’s engineering degrees awarded to students in Puerto Rico. In the same year, women made up only 23.2% of engineering faculty across ranks at UPR (Yoder, 2016). Due to a lack of representation, women faculty tend to be understudied about education literature. Recognizing this gap, the authors created the following research questions:

- How do Hispanic women engineering faculty at UPR describe their experiences?

- How can intersectionality theory (Crenshaw, 1991) be used to deconstruct these women’s experiences?

Theoretical Framework

In this empirical paper, authors draw from intersectionality theory to guide our analysis. Coined by Crenshaw (1991), this heuristic is useful for understanding how multiple social systems (such as race, class, gender, immigrant classification) work in tandem to privilege certain populations of people above others. In presenting this argument, Crenshaw underscores how non-White women often have to navigate multiple subordinations in order to survive. In taking up intersectionality theory, the authors aim to show how women at UPR have had to maneuver through politicized, overlapping systems of oppression (namely, class, political nepotism, and gender) in order persist as successful professors.

Methodology

The participants in this study are 10 tenured women faculty in engineering departments at the University of Puerto Rico (given the pseudonyms: Eleanor, Noelle, Ariana, Veronica, Selah, Minerva, Ida, Lola, Sydney, and Winnie). The authors employed a case-study qualitative approach (Yin, 2017) by asking each participant about her professional trajectory during in-person interviews. Epistemologically, the authors engaged in this research from a critical, feminist lens (Hesse-Biber, 2011; Lather, 1992).

Faculty interviewees were primarily at the rank of Full Professor (n=7) and Associate Professor (n=3). Additionally, the participants represented many engineering fields, including: mechanical, civil, industrial, electrical and computer engineering. In this proposal, authors will analyze data analysis from three specific participants, who are described below:
- Eleanor is a Full Professor of Civil Engineering. She mentioned that sexual harassment from male students has been a recurring phenomenon during time at UPR.
- Minerva is a Full Professor of Industrial Engineering. Before becoming an academic, she spent many years working in the engineering industry.
- Sydney is an Associate Professor of Mechanical Engineering. She manages an active research team while also working as an administrator in her department.

Findings

After completing open-coding of the audio-recorded interviews from all participants (n=10), the authors arrived at three emergent themes:

Theme 1: Women Faculty Navigate Highly Politicized Work Environments

UPR is a minority-serving institution (federally recognized as a Hispanic Serving Institution) as well as a public land-grant/sea-grant university (Hispanic Association of Colleges and Universities, 2018). UPR’s close relationship with the government, specifically, the Financial Oversight and Management Board (Government of Puerto Rico, 2018), has presented unique challenges for faculty.

For example, Eleanor described how governance of the UPR works to disadvantage women like her, who are not politically well-connected. During her interview, she shared that:

“Here, the chancellor is appointed by the governor, who changes every four years. Then the chancellor, in turn, appoints the dean of every college. So, after a while, you notice that the people who are in high positions are not necessarily the ones who are qualified, but the ones who know people at the top.”

For female faculty members like Eleanor—who has faced extensive sexual harassment from male students based on her appearance, age, and gender—the additional barrier of organizational nepotism makes faculty success arduous.

Theme 2: Women Faculty Do Not See Race as Salient

A second theme common among all women was the dismissal of racial identity as salient. Because the population of UPR is almost exclusively Hispanic and/or Latina/o (94%; College Board, 2018), Hispanic/Latina racial identity is perceived as normal. To this end, Minerva pointed out that other aspects of her identity (instead of race) are salient for her at work, such as her middle-class socioeconomic background and being a mother.

This finding is notable, considering how scholars of intersectionality often place an emphasis on racism as a fundamental category of oppression. In the case of women in Puerto Rico, their lived experiences in a racially homogenous country complicate our conceptualizations of how race and gender work together to subjugate women.

Theme 3: Women Faculty Value Long-Term Mentorship from Senior Scholars

Finally, participants in this study often described how mentors—particularly those with advanced careers—have been a source of support for them as they have maneuvered through the tenure track. For instance, Sydney mentioned:

“While I was in grad school, I was a part of the AGEP program and the Ford Foundation Fellowship. I met a lot of advanced faculty mentors through those programs, and I’ve kept in touch with them over the years.”

Sydney later explained how this type of extended mentorship is pivotal for women in her sub-discipline, which is especially male-dominated.

Implications

The findings from this empirical study have implications for organizational sustainability in Puerto Rican higher education and comparative education more broadly. Organizationally, the narratives of women in this study show how UPR’s classification as a Hispanic Serving Institution is not meaningful in a society that is almost exclusively Hispanic. Rather, institutional leaders should consider the actual realities of minority populations—such as women, individuals from lower socioeconomic groups, and members of minority political parties—when designing policies. Specifically, higher education leaders should consider formalizing mentorship programs to ensure that female faculty in engineering have support as they navigate the professoriate. In doing so, UPR has the potential to become the exemplar for other university systems in colonized island territories across the globe.

Authors