Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Improving the Relevance of Technical and Vocational Education and Training in Kenya: Lessons for Developing Economies in Sub-Saharan Africa and Beyond

Mon, April 15, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview A

Proposal

Educators, government officials, policymakers, and development experts generally concur that, if correctly implemented, technical vocational education and training (TVET) programs would create a highly employable workforce with relevant 21st-Century skills, prepared to be drivers of economic growth. In contribution to a partnership between the Harvard Ministerial Leadership Program and the Ministry of Education (MOE) in Kenya, a research team from the Harvard Graduate School of Education evaluated the existing Kenyan TVET system to first determine the most pressing challenges, and then to propose cost-effective and politically feasible policy alternatives.
Through its Strategic Plan 2018-2022, the TVET Authority (TVETA) in Kenya aims to address the mismatch in skills learned in post-secondary education by further developing the TVET system (Technical and Vocational Education and Training Authority, June 2018). Goals within this plan include increased equity and access, improved governance and management, and sustainable funding and financing, the linchpin of which is the ability to ensure the employability of TVET graduates in a dynamic, globalizing economy. However, the implementation and success of the national TVET system in Kenya has faced several critical obstacles, including limited resources, rapidly changing markets, and low public perception of TVET. Mechanisms to adequately ensure the relevance of TVET instruction are currently absent. The TVETA notes its lack of a quality assurance framework, comprehensive occupational standards, sufficient engagement with the labor market and stakeholders, and engagement among Technical Vocational Centers (TVCs) and other training providers. The demand for education and training comes primarily from youth ages 15-24, the demographic with the highest stake in the relevance of Kenyan TVET as they are most strongly impacted by unemployment and most likely to seek employable skills from the education system. Kenya’s youth unemployment rate is not only significant relative to their older compatriots, but also to other countries in the region; while the average rate of youth unemployment in 2018 for Sub-Saharan African nations was 13.9%, Kenya’s stands at 26.2%. Until policies address these deficiencies, they will minimize any benefit from further TVET expansion (International Labour Organization, ILOSTAT, 2018; Kenya National Bureau of Statistics, 2018).
Over the course of six months, the research team conducted both remote and in-country research. Initial research used publicly available data and reports to identify key policy issues hampering the existing TVET system, review literature regarding 21st-century competency development, and determine potential policy alternatives to address the issue. Based on the literature, the issue of relevance to the current and emerging labor markets was identified as the major hindrance to the successful implementation of TVET policy, not only in Kenya but in TVET programs throughout developing economies. Following the conclusion of this initial research, the team established focal points for in-country research and traveled to Kenya to gather additional information from stakeholders, such as TVET providers, corporations and businesses, international donors, the MOE, international donors, youths, parents, TVCs, and advocacy groups. Remote and in-country interviews were coordinated by both the Kenyan Government and the research team.
After synthesizing information from both research phases of the project, the team concluded that the most disabling lack of relevance in TVET existed in its curriculum, pedagogy and infrastructure, and that public-private partnerships (P3s) in TVET would provide the most sustainable and cost-effective strategy for improving relevance. In analyzing potential policies for improving the relevance of TVET in Kenya, the research team relied upon existing evaluative tools in the fields of TVET, workforce development, and 21st century competencies. To center analysis on the MOE and TVETA’s priorities and within the Kenyan context, a combination of evaluative metrics was used including but not limited to: cost, timeframe, scalability, equity, political feasibility, connection to the private sector (formal and informal), TVC enrollment rates, TVC graduation rates, TVC graduate employment rates, and the public perception of TVET overall. Three policy alternatives related to P3s were analyzed: (1) incorporate corporations and medium and small enterprises into skills-mapping planning and process for the purpose of curriculum design and development, (2) raise teaching quality by increasing the qualifications levels required of TVET teachers, making ongoing professional development obligatory and in coordination with private sector, and recruiting instructors from private sector, and (3) increase funding to improve learning environments by providing mentoring, on-the-job training and improve infrastructure.
The recommendation offered by the research team is of significance not only to Kenya, but also to countries in similar contexts. TVET is often viewed as the panacea for the widening skills gap in increasingly technological and globalized economies; however, its success hinges on its responsiveness to labor market demands (Subrahmanyam, 2014; Law, 2010). The use of P3s has risen over the past decade, with major international organizations and funders increasingly recommending these collective impact models for development (Patrinos et. al., 2009; Johanson et. al., 2004). The conclusions from this research demonstrate that existing P3s patterns can be efficiently adapted to include collaboration for TVET development, linking the often-separated ministries and markets of labor and education to resolve issues challenging economic development - from reducing youth unemployment and its consequences to providing an adequate supply of labor to supporting the prevention or containment of environmental crises.
Moving forward, the research team would recommend a larger comparative study of TVET systems in Sub-Saharan Africa to compare the viability of P3s to increase relevance within developing economies of similar scale and geographic challenges. While this research was aimed at developing policy alternatives to increase relevance, the long-term goal was to contribute to overall economic development by building the workforce for current and emerging labor markets, strengthening the relationship between the Kenyan government and local businesses, and encouraging entrepreneurship and innovation within the Kenyan context to abate ongoing and impending environmental and economic crisis. Therefore, longitudinal studies that track the impact of increased relevance, or the metrics by which this research team assessed relevance such as public perception, enrollment rates, and graduation rates within national TVCs, are critical

Authors