Session Submission Summary

Nurturing care: building evidence for program implementation and effectiveness_session II

Mon, April 15, 3:15 to 4:45pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview B

Group Submission Type: Refereed Round-Table Session

Proposal

This panel is the third in a series of three proposed panels relating to the Nurturing Care Framework (NCF) released by WHO and UNICEF in 2018. The NCF recognizes the critical importance of the enabling environment that surrounds a child, and the role that multiple sectors play to protect, nourish, and stimulate optimal development. The framework builds on the growing body of literature displaying the importance of high quality inputs from multiple sectors for children’s development, and advocates for inter-sectoral collaboration (Black et al., 2016). One of the most common collaborations that has been growing with the launch of the NCF is the integration of early stimulation and responsive caregiving programs with newborn and child health initiatives.
Inter-sectoral programs offer many efficiencies and opportunities for strengthening existing services, but they also present added complexity for program delivery as well as for program monitoring and evaluation. Incorporating actors from multiple sectors brings additional perspectives and outcomes of interest. For example, a health sector program might focus on improving child development through the reduction of stunting, whereas an early stimulation program might conceptualize improved child development as stronger cognitive outcomes. In this way, two groups can propose to be working towards the same goal of improved child development but the activities undertaken and the outcomes measured differ widely. Therefore when such programs come together, the way child development is defined and measured needs to be expanded or modified for both groups.
In addition, inter-sectoral programs often involve adding workload or changing responsibilities for existing service providers. One shortcoming that has been identified within the expansion of community health worker networks is that they can become overburdened with too many responsibilities, which reduces effectiveness (DiGirolamo, Stansbery, & Lung’aho, 2014). This shift in working practices makes implementation fidelity critical to monitor. Further, health systems have many different levels of health works who vary in their professional and educational backgrounds, as well as the extent to which they interact with young children and families. Program implementers must gain an understanding of which cadre of health worker is the most appropriate to deliver messages to the target beneficiaries.
This panel will showcase examples of how organizations are establishing monitoring frameworks and conducting evaluations that meet the needs of both child health and early stimulation practitioners in different contexts around the world. This panel will share evidence from both development and emergency contexts. World Vision will discuss the results of a quantitative evaluation measuring the impact of a program designed to support the physical, cognitive and psychological needs of Palestinian children and their caregivers. IRC will share data from studies of ECD services that leverage the different available entry points for reaching the youngest Syrian refugees in Jordan, Lebanon and Syria. Finally, researchers from NYU will discuss results of a qualitative study of the integration of early learning and responsive care content into a state-wide health-system in Central India.

Sub Unit

Chair

Individual Presentations

Discussant