Session Submission Summary

Sustainability in a mobile education world--at scale

Tue, April 16, 1:30 to 3:00pm, Hyatt Regency, Floor: Bay (Level 1), Bayview A

Group Submission Type: Refereed Round-Table Session

Proposal

World-wide data have shown that mobile access, via Internet or even 2G mobile networks, has reached ¾ of the world’s population. This has provided an unprecedented level of potential connectivity for even some of the poorest regions of the world. In support of education, for purposes of administration, accountability, and instruction of both teachers and students, such connectivity provides many new options. Key among these is the ability to overcome the previous manual processes that have information from the lowest level (the school or learning site) moving a “tortuous” path through various administrative levels (sometimes as many as four) before reaching both those making policy decisions and commanding resources. Secondly, reliable text or data transmissions have the possibility of inexpensively reaching an entire system simultaneously, both with the exact same message, and quickly. Certain “filtering” of both content and speed then becomes less—improving overall accuracy.
As importantly, particularly for administration and accountability, the key “players” in an educational system, the headteachers, teachers, students, and parents potentially receive identical information, almost at the same time, as those at remote levels. The power of this enhanced access to educational substance brings with it the responsibility to ensure good policy of use, support so that such mechanisms remain viable, and capacity to make needed incremental changes as conditions change. All of this requires an overarching approach to something that may have begun as the use of “new tools.”
Based on over 10 years of system strengthening work in multiple school systems internationally, this panel will explore some key determinants of success for sustainability, and highlight the comparative improvements that affect lower income and lower middle income countries at scale. Here “at scale” means covering at least 1/3 of known schools with plans to encompass all known schools in the country. Particular attention will be given to experiences in Tanzania (8,000 plus schools), in Ghana (7,200 schools), and Nigeria (up to 1,000 schools).
The three panelists will discuss three topical areas, building upon applied research, originally funded by USAID under the EQUIP II global improvement project, and further elaborated with the support of DfID in the case of Tanzania. Additionally, the panelists will use very concrete implementation experiences using a variety of mobile tools, and a recently completed, tablet based m360 School Information System.
1) Preconditions for Sustainability
2) Balancing Implementation Challenges
3) Creating System Imperatives After the Project







1) Preconditions for Sustainability need to deal with the Political, Institutional and Technical aspects of proposed interventions—in concert with many other types of improvement, Political elements require both those immediate recipients (schools, parents, teachers) as well as the most supportive or active intermediate administrative layers (ward, woreda or district) and the most senior levels that fundamentally allocate system resources—prime minister, president, or cabinet level officials. This is helped immensely if key indicators and perceived outcomes, such as attendance, and use of funds, are shared by all levels of the administrative support for education.

2) Balancing Implementation Challenges relates to the interplay of all three above components. Typically, in systems where communications infrastructure is not fully developed, or not capable of fully supporting a national scale, then Technical challenges become very critical. If previous institutional factors are associated with prior political groups, or so practiced that they become the new standard, whatever approach is used needs to respond to these “successful” efforts. As one example, the MSI developed, USAID endorsed checklist for “scaling” may be a useful checklist. This will be explored in the session not only theoretically, but also in terms of a specific set of software/hardware tablet solutions—specifically the School Information System developed by FHI360 and the integrated Fidelity of Implementation (FOI) framework in use in Ghana and Nigeria. This will include an audience involved demonstration—of the entire cycle of work and presentation.


3) Creating System Imperatives After the Project involved linking the “sensitization” in the first part of preconditions, to both the desire and ability for the intervention to be absorbed within the existing government structure. In most instances, this still involves the three above elements, political, institutional, and technical but focusses critically on: enough political and institutional consensus that the education results are worth pursuing, and there is political will to allocate resources to make sure the change continues, absent additional or exclusively project-based funding. This requires that as part of an intervention that sufficient skills and leadership at a technical level are in place within the government to ensure that solely technical issues are not hindering the outcome. It also requires that the key political stakeholders all see benefits to themselves oriented to the best possible good for education for children. This means that contextualization and localization are critical to ensure that policy goals become understandable to key stakeholders. Institutionalization needs to ensure that there is a path of transition, sensitive to power relationships within a bureaucracy. This section of the presentation will provide examples from selected parts of the three key countries, Tanzania, Ghana, and Nigeria and remind the listener of the concrete examples of actual implementation.

The issue of scale becomes critical for sustainability in part because national divergence always complicates top-down, or bottom-up implementation. But, secondly movement of funds, and perceived “prejudice” are always at stake in any issue that involves both children and funding. Our examples of implementation will describe how these have been reviewed and assessed.

Sub Unit

Presenters

Individual Presentations