Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

We are not ready! Contradictions and contestations in education organising in South Africa at the advent of the Covid19 pandemic

Wed, April 20, 9:30 to 11:00am CDT (9:30 to 11:00am CDT), Hyatt Regency - Minneapolis, Nicollet D2

Proposal

As the first serious wave of Covid19 infections gained momentum in South Africa in late March of 2020, various education unions, NGOs, community-based organisations, academics and activists came together to formulate responses from the education sector to government emergency legislation that constituted one of the harshest initial Covid lockdowns in the world. This presentation reflects on the authors’ direct participation in two such movements--the C19 People’s Coalition (in both the Basic and Higher Education Working Groups), and the Progressive Organisations Formation (POF) in the Western Cape. Through a reflective account of the struggles and issues in both groups, we lift out commonalities and differences that reflect the broader conditions of education labour and community struggles in contemporary South Africa.

We argue our observations are indicative of a broader political climate in which large-scale, organised resistance based on a common unifying narrative and borne out in praxis is relatively absent in the ‘post-1994’ context. The fundamental reorganising that took place in the 1990s saw many anti-apartheid forces in education being neutralised: radical Student Representative Council (SRC) movements merged with the conservative politics of prefect systems to become ‘Representative Councils for Learners’ (RCLS), and vibrant parent, teacher and student associations (PTSAs) merged into relatively politically ineffectual school governing bodies (SGBs). In a similar manner, radical and democratic education unions were co-opted into the tri-apartheid alliance with the ruling African National Congress (ANC) and the South African Communist Party (SACP). Unions suffered additional losses when leaders were absorbed into both the management of the state and corporate sector management. Weaker forms of people’s organisations have thus been absorbed into the state machine and continue to act as buffers against more radical forms of resistance.

What our direct experiences of teacher organising during Covid suggested is the state of unreadiness of South African education organisations, given this historical co-option, to both handle unexpected exogenous shocks or sustain protracted struggles on any given issue or concern. The original declaration of the C19 People’s Coalition Basic Education WG, “We are not ready!” could not have been more ironic.

Authors