Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Improving Literacy Instruction and Learners’ Reading outcomes through Classroom-based Group Administered Learning Assessments: Lessons from Tanzania

Fri, April 22, 11:15am to 12:45pm CDT (11:15am to 12:45pm CDT), Hyatt Regency - Minneapolis, Nicollet D1

Proposal

Authors:
Maurice Sikenyi ([email protected])
Pinaki Joddar ([email protected])

Educational research reveals the value of classroom-based assessment in providing feedback to teachers on the quality of learning by giving insights into student’s mastery of the learning content covered (Gebriel 2021; Tsagari, 2016; URT 2016). Results from classroom-based assessments constitute important data for actions that can improve students’ mastery of skills, the focus for remedial activities, and shape teachers’ pedagogical practices including adoption of new instruction approaches (Muskin, 2017). However, in the global south, teachers’ administration and use of students’ continuous assessment data is hampered by many factors such as teacher workload, inadequate material resources, and the large classroom enrollment. In Tanzania, recent national education reports reveal the challenges of larger enrollments on educational quality at all levels of learning, particularly, at the pre-primary and primary levels. For instance, in 2016, the country reported a Pupil to Qualified Teachers Ratio of 1:131 against the standard norm of 1:25. The case was worse in government schools whose classes had a PQTR of 1:169 compared to 1:24 for Non-Government Schools (URT, 2016). These high enrollments pose great challenges to teachers’ administration, grading and timely utilization of continuous assessment data to improve learning outcomes. Building on recent works on Group Administered Learning Assessments (GALA) as alternatives to traditional individualized assessments (USAID, 2013; RTI, 2013), this research explores the potential of GALA as an alternative approach to individually administered classroom-based assessment for monitoring early grade learners’ reading skills in Tanzania. The research seeks to address the following research questions:
1. What are the experiences of administering Group Administered Learning Assessment as a potential alternative for classroom-based individual student reading skills assessments for teachers in Tanzania?
2. How do student’s reading skills compare across various types of classroom-based reading skills assessments, such as group-based, individual oral administration or written assessment?
3. What recommendations/lessons can be drawn from GALA administration to support early grade literacy teacher instruction approaches and students’ learning outcomes?
The study is designed into two phases with an initial GALA pre-pilot phase in a small number of schools and students in 2021, and a second phase of a full GALA administration with a larger sample of schools and students in 2022. This paper presents findings from the GALA pre pilot administration which was conducted with Grade 1 (n=124) and Grade 2 ((n=99) students, in Tanga Province, Tanzania. Data was collected on various reading skills tasks including letter sounding recognition, syllable reading, familiar and nonsense word reading, oral reading fluency, reading comprehension and paired sentence choice subtask. Three different processes with similar assessments items were administered: 1st process, a group administered learning assessment with all students in each class; the 2nd process, an individualized oral EGRA administration of GALA to 25% of children randomly selected from the 1st process, and the 3rd process, an individual written administration of GALA subtasks to 25% of the children selected randomly from the children who participated in the 1st process. Moreover, classroom observation data and student experience survey data were collected. Preliminary findings suggest similarities in students reading skills outcomes across Group Administered Learning Assessments and individualized oral and written assessment, but also differences in student’s item-wise responses across the various assessment approaches. The study provides lessons on group-based assessments as alternative approaches to generating student monitoring data to improve learning outcomes in under-resourced and highly populated education systems.

Author