Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
This research is aimed at understanding the dilemma of a community-building project which I observe and participate in as an academic volunteer and advisor. The project was initiated by a grassroot NGO specialized in rural development to renovate and co-construct a community space in an ethnic minority village that is one of the most typical "untypical" – “unexemplary” in China. This village gains very little attention from both the government and entrepreneurs for it is too ordinary: ordinarily poor, ordinary ethnic style, located far away from any administrative center. It is also encountering the most common problems of rural development in China that young people especially young women are constantly leaving the village while children and elders consist most of the current residents.
To solve this problem in a long run, the NGO renovated a community space in the village to make it function in three ways. First, it provides a place of complimentary education for children in this village where the NGO brings in high-quality educational resources including books, toys, musical instruments, electronic devices, learning activities, etc. Second, it is to help accumulate Qi (气, atmosphere) of the village and to unite villagers to take care of each other and the village as a whole. Third, it also works as a zone of culture encounter and connection between local villagers and outside volunteers. The ultimate goal of this project is to activate local villagers to regain confidence in their own culture and land and take responsibilities for building this community space by themselves.
I joined this community-building project as a volunteer and advisor in the middle with an ethical and political commitment to, what Jacques Rancière (2016) called, “the method of equality.” Rather than setting up equality as the goal to be achieved or arrogantly being the prophet who knows the rule of the (re)production of inequality and teaches the poor how to get a better life, we practice equality out as a method to create possibilities and activate abilities of living-together. That means suspending the existing hierarchy and opposition between the urban and the rural, the "knowledgeable" and the "ignorant," and avoiding preaching “the” truth to the villagers. We certainly recognize that this community space nonetheless functions in a pedagogical way through which the local villagers can unlearn and relearn their surroundings and daily life, recall and relive their memories of togetherness, (re)gain abilities and confidence in opening up more opportunities and imaginations of their own futures, and the insiders and outsiders and the elders and the young can acknowledge and empower each other. We see this community space as an ongoing lived curriculum through which knowledges, ideas, experiences, feelings, memories from different actors are organized, convened, and presented.
However, after running this project for three years, the NGO found that although some children and parents showed their interest, fondness and appreciation towards the volunteers and educational activities they brought in, villagers still did not feel that they were the owners of this community space and they either kept themselves away from the community space or used it irresponsibly. As both the village officials and the villagers insisted they were too "weak" and "unable" (不会)to take good care of both the space and even their own children and thus waiting for the NGO to tell them what to do or to directly “throw” resource to them, the project was not moving towards but away from its own goal. In another word, the sustainability of this project was severely challenged. We also began to doubt the meaning of devoting ourselves to this project. We kept asking, why we, the outsiders, cared this community more “deeply” than them who actually belonged to this village and bore the negative effects of inequality. The answer was also simple: We cared because (we thought) we know the structure of inequality. We believed the villagers had the capacity and desire to develop their community as long as there were sufficient and adequate support from the outsiders. But?
But, do we really know “them”? Do we really know how their community has worked from the past to the present? To redistribute the sensible as a method of equality requires us to first understand and feel how the sensible has worked and has been distributed in this particular village. Talking to different families helped me realize that one of the mistakes or mis-assumptions that we made was to take the village as if it was “one community.” To the officials and villagers, to different family kinships, and to the elders and the young, the village means and works in very different ways. To understand the problem of “incapacity” and “irresponsibility” but also change this dilemma of community co-building, it is necessary to examine the history and cultural politics of community space and community education in this particular village. Based on the review of historical studies of Dong ethnic group (侗族) and interviews with different kinds of actors (e.g., teachers and principals of the village primary school, parents who leave the village, parents who stay in the village, merchants, drivers, village officials), this research will examine the local understanding of community/collectivity and its changes across time, the changing relationship between families and individuals, responsibilities and rights as officials and common people, and also multiple relationships that have already been constructed between the village(rs) and the outside(rs) as the effects of governmental reforms, educational trends, economic reform, migrant work and life, and mobile media.