Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Committee or SIG
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keywords
Browse By Geographic Descriptor
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Narrowing educational inequality between students who are from rich and low-income families has become a focus of research and policy debate at the global level and in the field of international education and development. The Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4) focus on ensuring equitable quality education for all exemplifies the global focus on addressing inequalities. Specifically, narrowing this gap by enabling youths to pursue and realize their aspirations has become a focus of educational research and educational policy debate (Hart, 2012).
In Ethiopia, economically disadvantaged students are not equally represented in the education system, in terms of enrollment and attendance. The high dropout and low completion rates of these groups widen the educational inequalities in the country. The government of Ethiopia has sought to allocate resources to narrow the educational inequality, but the policy framework is not based on the capabilities of students or their ability to utilize resources to move forward to their aspired futures. Nonetheless, previous studies in Ethiopia focus on the availability of educational resources and students’ outcomes, instead of examining real educational opportunities. To fill the gap in the literature, this study aims to examine the availability of resources and the youth’s ability to use these resources to pursue their aspirations. Specifically, this study aims to answer the following research question: How do in-school and out-of-school conditions support or constrain youth’s ability to pursue their aspirations?
I mainly argue that providing resources and means does not predict or indicate equal educational opportunities for all unless those opportunities are real. Real opportunities are when students from disadvantaged backgrounds, specifically those who are from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, can use the opportunities to pursue their aspirations. This argument is framed within a capability approach, which assesses not only the provision of resources but also the availability of “real opportunities or capabilities” that translate into the actual use of resources, thus allowing people the freedom to be what they want to be (see McCowan, 2011; Sen, 1999). Research on how to bridge the gap between resource availability and actual use is vital to identifying educational advantages and disadvantages that result in educational outcomes. Towards this end, in this study, much emphasis is given to conditions affecting the transformation of aspirations into real opportunities by examining what personal, familiar, societal, and school-related conditions help or prevent the youth to pursue their aspirations.
In this study, I centered the voices of economically disadvantaged youths using a narrative, life history approach. As such, the study narrates the life history of six secondary school-age youth in Dire Dawa, Ethiopia (four in-school and two out of school) and their educational aspirations and their abilities to work towards achieving their aspired future. Narrating the life history of the economically disadvantaged youths centers their voices to give insight to policymakers while honoring their lived experiences.
The youths’ stories reveal the multi-dimensional aspects affecting the capability to pursue their aspired futures, including familial, school-related, and societal conditions, as well as personal effort in nurturing interest. As such, the findings confirm that having a clear map of their future journey is not enough for economically disadvantaged youth to be able to pursue and realize their aspirations. Even though the youth indicate the lack of educational resources, a more recurring finding was the extent to which youth are unable to use even the existing educational resources to follow their aspirations due to many conditions.
Family economic situation, family responsibility, societal perception about the importance of education, and teachers’ inability to understand the struggle of these disadvantaged students, labeling practice at schools based on academic performance, and language barriers are among some of the reasons mentioned by the study participants as constraining. In a showing example, the participants mentioned how they lacked the attention to learn during class sessions as they were either hungry or sleep-deprived from the daily labor work they had to do to financially support their family. Thus, the findings confirm that educational inequality cannot be addressed by only expanding resources, underlining the importance of familial, societal, and school-related conditions in influencing the youths’ ability to use these resources to pursue their desired future.
The youths’ narratives further highlight that family economic conditions are mostly limiting, and societal and school support is crucial for individuals to pursue their aspirations. Sometimes, there is a double or triple burden on economically disadvantaged youths as being poor limits their abilities to go to school. Poverty also creates a societal challenge, as people do not expect them to go to school or get employment, and their situation is sometimes misrecognized by their teachers. Besides societal conditions, teachers’ emotional and material support enable students to keep pursuing their aspirations amid obstacles, as the findings highlight. There were also times wherein teachers and members of the society served as parental figure roles by providing emotional and material support that enabled the youth in their educational path.
Thus, interventions by governments should focus on enhancing supporting conditions and removing constraints so that youth can ultimately reach their aspirations. This research could inform the next phase of the GEQIP by yielding insights for policymakers to shift the emphasis from equality of resources and equality of outcomes to equality of capabilities (real opportunities). This requires furthering the understanding of youth’s experience at the local level and examining the existence of real opportunities in a way that reveals what matters for the youth. This contribution can also be extended to other developing countries that are applying educational reforms by underscoring the necessity of looking at not only the provision of resources but also the ability of students to use these resources to achieve their valued future. Especially at this time when the COVID-19 pandemic widened educational inequalities throughout the world and in Ethiopia, it is essential to consider the different conditions influencing the ability of students to pursue their aspirations to prevent exacerbating existing inequalities.