Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

From Axes to Multidimensionality: Catalyzing Identity Complexity in Intersectionality Research with Youth in Pakistan and the United States

Mon, February 20, 2:45 to 4:15pm EST (2:45 to 4:15pm EST), Grand Hyatt Washington, Floor: Constitution Level (3B), Constitution E

Proposal

Our cross-national research team is in the process of conducting qualitative research guided by intersectionality theory to explore high school students’ identity-based schooling experiences in the United States and Pakistan. Contextualized intersectional data analysis across national and local contexts illuminates lessons for theory-building in the realm of intersectionality theory and methods-building in multidimensional identity-based research.

Design and Methods:
Triangulated qualitative methods, including on-site observational fieldnotes, surface students’ emic, or insider, conceptualizations of how social identities and contextual mediators shape their schooling experiences, opportunities, and access. 20 Philadelphia high schoolers in urban neighborhood, charter, and independent schools and 50 Pakistani high schoolers in urban and rural public schools and private independent co-educational schools have been interviewed thus far. 1:1 interviews include Culturegrams, a pedagogical tool for surfacing layers of identity. Fieldnotes are processed and data are coded for thematic analysis in weekly research team meetings.

Methodological Redux:
Transnational qualitative research is a powerful tool for 1) examining intersectional identities in a way that surfacies problematic gaps in Western research methods; and 2) illuminating the dire need to challenge Western research epistemology and constructions of identity, especially in applied research. Challenging Western epistemology as it becomes instantiated in research design and method creates possibilities for positioning intersectionality research as a more precise tool for generating nuanced intersectional analysis of structural and familial oppression, uncovering layers of identity complexity in ways that enhance fidelity to participants’ lived experiences, especially in non-Western contexts (Chilisa, 2020). Ensuring diverse identity composition on our research team proved invaluable in ways that challenged our entire project. Diverse researcher identities must be endemic to teams in authentic, non-tokenizing ways to avoid falling prey to Western binaries and deficitization.

We initially used intersectionality theory; however, our theoretical framing, and thus our methodology, proved to be insufficiently comprehensive and nuanced. Intersectionality theory focuses on axes of structural oppression in a U.S. context, however culture and ethnicity has structural potency in Pakistan in ways that require a broadening of the framework. Intersectionality theory illuminates the confluence of structural oppressions on identity markers such as race, social class, sexual and gender identity (Shakeir, 2019). Our practice-based interactions with Pakistani team members and participants expanded our conceptions of intersectionality to include cultural, ethnic, language, and regional identities; these intersect with and create contextualized axes of oppression that expand Crenshaw’s.

Contextual identity markers are impactful mediating factors that illuminate the importance of adopting a stance of construct fluidity vis-a-vis identity; they shape lived experience and increase the fidelity of research in terms of honoring participant experiences (Ravitch & Carl, 2021). This stance can benefit transnational identity-based research and iterate intersectionality theory in global remit. We argue that 1:1 application of intersectionality theory in non-U.S. contexts is necessarily the wrong empirical approach, as the condition of Western research belies humanization and identity complexity (Chilisa, 2020). We see how we inadvertently exported Westernist research to Pakistan through our study even as we worked to resist doing so.

Author