Attitudes and perceptions regarding algorithmic judicial judgement: barriers to innovation in the judicial system?

• In Event: Attitude towards Crime and Punishment

Abstract

The presentation discusses a study from project TED2021-129356B-I00, funded by MCIN/AEI and the EU's NextGenerationEU/PRTR. It serves as a starting point for examining attitudes and perceptions regarding the use of algorithmic tools in the judicial sector, as well as identifying potential obstacles to innovation within this field. The study uncovers variances in acceptance levels among the general public, data and AI experts, and legal professionals, with the latter group exhibiting skepticism due to concerns about objectivity, fairness, and adherence to legal principles. The research also points out the challenges in integrating these tools, highlighting the complexity of tasks and the necessity for a balance between automation and human supervision. Ultimately, it emphasizes the importance of a thoughtful approach by both society and legal professionals to successfully incorporate algorithmic tools into the judicial system.

Authors

• Sandra Pérez, Universidad Miguel Hernandez - Crímina

• Pere Simón, Universidad Internacional de la Rioja (UNIR)