Female is the New Black: Examining How Gender Trumps Race in Stand Your Ground Cases

• In Event: Intergroup Communication Research in Progress

Abstract

Much of the popular press and scientific literature paints a picture of bleak picture for the future of race relations. Some argue that rather than ushering in a more inclusive era of inter-group relations, the increasing diversity in the U.S. may instead yield an increase of intergroup hostility gender inequality and overall discrimination. However, recent scholarship suggests intergroup relations may not be as grim as previously suggested. A bourgeoning body of work suggests Americans are becoming more egalitarian in their racial and gender beliefs. The purpose of this study is to analyze the effect of the race and gender of criminal suspects featured in news stories has on readers’ perceptions of criminality in cases in which suspects invoke Stand Your Ground laws as a defense. It finds in such cases the salience of gender may supersede negative perceptions of race in assigning guilt and determining sentencing.

Authors

• Lanier Frush Holt, Ohio State U

• Osei Appiah, Ohio State U

• Katherine R. Dale, Ohio State University

• Tiffany White, Ohio State U