The Unbearable Lightness of Communication Research

Session Submission Type: Panel

Abstract

There are at least six deficiencies in communication research. First, we have never developed our own set of disciplinary problems on which science depends. Instead we have been derivative. Second, we are following the dead-end trail of cognitivism, which makes little sense in what is a dynamic field. Third, we are still using methods developed nearly 100 years ago. Our statistical sophistication far outstrips our ability to measure and quantify. Fourth, we have failed to return something of value to society. Instead, we chase technology, culture, and participate in moral panics. Fifth, we are not paying enough attention to what is going on in other disciplines, and are therefore not interdisciplinary enough. And last, we have no clinical practice, meaning that we have very low utility to society at large. And maybe a seventh, we are far too content with our current state and our "also participated" trophies.

These frank and provocative statements will form the starting point for a hopefully engaged and forward looking discussion, starting with the panelists mentioned and the public at large.

Sub Unit

• Philosophy, Theory and Critique

Chairs

• James A. Anderson, U of Utah

• Jan E. Servaes, City U of Hong Kong

Participants

• Francois Cooren, U de Montreal

• Gary Gumpert, Urban Communication Foundation

• John Hartley, Curtin U

• Chin-Chuan Lee, City U of Hong Kong

• Robin Elizabeth Mansell, London School of Economics and Political Science

• Dennis K. Mumby, U of North Carolina - Chapel Hill

• Mohan Jyoti Dutta, National U of Singapore