Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Division
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Session Submission Type: Panel
Over the past decade, research about the diversity of viewpoints in the news has made significant advances. Building upon increasingly refined conceptual definitions, methodological tools, and the opportunities for comparative research afforded by digital media, scholars have probed numerous concerns related to the production of diverse news coverage, addressing journalistic routines, economic and political contexts, and many other driving factors. However, the further research advances in explaining the amount (or lack) of diversity generated in the media, the more does it become apparent that not all ‘diverse’ voices are created equal: Different voices contribute to the debate in different ways, and different conditions generate different kinds and deficits of viewpoint diversity. Moreover, depending on the normative, regulatory or journalistic professional perspectives applied, the same added voices may be judged to add different value – or even decrease the quality of the news.
In this panel, we aim to spark a scholarly debate on the production and implications of viewpoint diversity that shifts focus away from a quantitatively understood demand for “more” diversity, and toward an understanding of the different ways in which diverse voices contribute to actualizing important qualities in the debate. We bring together scholars addressing diversity from the vantage point of different disciplinary and methodological perspectives, drawing on recent data from six different countries. The presentations span the process from the structural conditions and regulations shaping journalistic production, over the practices and decisions in the newsroom, to the measurement and normative appraisal of diversity achieved in the coverage. Each contribution raises important contingencies in the production of viewpoint diversity and points toward open questions for advancing theory and research in journalism studies.
Rodney Benson examines how media ownership interacts with specifics of the national journalistic field to create different patterns and deficiencies in news diversity. Helle Sjøvaag then discusses how regulatory interventions into these conditions are rendered ineffective by journalistic professionalism and culture, which are geared toward a rather different understanding of viewpoint diversity. Addressing the need to gauge news diversity in a multidimensional perspective, Judith Möller and Damian Trilling present an algorithmic approach capable of scaling the contribution of diverse voices with regard to their different aspects and qualities. Christian Baden subsequently discusses how additional viewpoints may at times fail to contribute or even subtract from the quality of the news, raising the possibility of excessive diversity. Natali Helberger, finally ties those patterns and distinctions raised by the four papers back to the normative foundations informing the study of diversity, its qualities and limits.
Explaining News Diversity: The Roles of Institutional Ownership vs. National Fields - Rodney Benson, Rodney Benson
The limits of regulation on the diversity of news - Helle Sjovaag, University of Stavanger
Expecting the Unexpected: Conceptualizing Diversity as Relative Distance in a Multidimensional Feature Ppace - Judith Moeller, U of Amsterdam; Damian Trilling, U of Amsterdam
What the journalist dragged in: On the limits and excesses of viewpoint diversity - Christian Baden, Hebrew U of Jerusalem