ERROR: relation "aaa200401_proceeding_action_tracker" does not exist LINE 1: INSERT INTO aaa200401_proceeding_action_tracker(action_track... ^There was an unexpected database error.ERROR: relation "aaa200401_proceeding_action_tracker" does not exist LINE 1: INSERT INTO aaa200401_proceeding_action_tracker(action_track... ^There was an unexpected database error.Auditing Section Midyear Meeting: Auditing the Fair Values of Investment Securities: An Examination of Auditor Expertise and Response to Risk Cues
Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Auditing the Fair Values of Investment Securities: An Examination of Auditor Expertise and Response to Risk Cues

Sat, January 18, 10:15 to 11:45am, TBA

Abstract

PCAOB inspections and recent field research highlight difficulties faced by auditors when testing fair value estimates. In this study, we exploit a unique dataset with security-level fair value estimates for property and casualty (P&C) insurers to better understand variation in auditors’ performance in this difficult area. Specifically, we predict that auditors with greater expertise have the knowledge, experience, and status to identify deviations and require adjustments such that they reduce fair value errors. We also examine whether auditor expertise is associated with incremental reductions in fair value errors in the presence of situational cues suggesting a heightened risk of material misstatement. To empirically test our predictions, we use two different types of auditor expertise (Big 4 and local-level industry expertise) and the interaction of these expert auditors with four different high-risk cues (opportunistic fair value level classification, internal as opposed to third-party pricing method, prior period inflation in the aggregate investment portfolio, and prior period bias in another significant estimate). Our findings indicate that auditors with greater expertise are associated with significant reductions in both inflation and deflation of security-level fair values. Moreover, the auditor’s ability to effectively identify and incorporate information from the cues varies based on the type of cue and auditor expertise. Overall, our study informs existing research and practice by highlighting factors affecting auditors’ ability to evaluate complex fair value estimates.

Authors