Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Rancière and Education Research: Troubling the Idea of (Virtual) Communities of Practice

Fri, April 13, 12:00 to 1:30pm, Sheraton Wall Centre, Floor: Grand Ballroom Level, North Grand Ballroom C

Abstract

In this presentation, I will focus on questions which Rancière’s work raises for research methodology in education. Specifically, I will analyse the continuities and discontinuities between his conception of collectivity and approaches to the analysis of communities of practice. The presentation will be informed by how the concept of community of practice has been drawn upon to analyse the pedagogies of online spaces – or ‘virtual communities’. I will explore Rancière’s work to highlight problems and tensions with how ‘communities’ are identified methodologically in education research, and the ethical and political implications of using the figure of ‘community participation’ as a way of making learning perceptible.

The concept of ‘community of practice’ has been widely adopted in education research to describe how people learn through ‘legitimate peripheral participation’ in expert practices. The claim that learning is a way of naming patterns of participation in community living resonates with certain principles of ‘universal teaching’, described in Rancière’s The Ignorant Schoolmaster. In each case, learning, or knowing, is identified in terms of evolving and continuously renewed relations among people and artefacts in activity, a move which focuses analysis on the practices by which knowledge is recognized within a community, rather than on whether knowledge is possessed. However, Rancière’s account of community/collectivity as founded in disagreement and emerging as a polemical claim to be a participant, contrasts with a belief in, and attachment to, notions of progressively increasing legitimacy in the communities of practice literature, as well as with the latter’s figuring of community as something constituted by a core and a periphery. The implications of this contrast will be explored in relation to research in the field of educational technology, where the ‘communities of practice’ concept has frequently been recruited to construct accounts of the pedagogies of ‘popular’ sites of learning. My argument will be that in identifying legitimate, progressive forms of participation, such accounts demonstrate certain phenomena which Rancière criticizes strongly in sociological research: namely, the linking of particular bodies with particular/ ‘popular’ forms of feeling, judging and feeling (hence ‘situated learning’); the definition of community in terms of a binding ethos / identity (a move which makes disagreement appears as peripherality); and a justificatory account of mastery/expertise/governance which explains inequality by showing its legitimacy (rather than contingency). The value of Rancière’s work will be explored in terms of how it makes communities of practice appear differently: rather than seeing communities as bound by a common set of values, interests or sensibilities, to be achieved by learners in some distant future as they endlessly progress towards ‘full participation’, Rancière’s work can be drawn on to make scenes of confrontations appear, between what is common, and over what is common. The significance of such scenes will be related to feminist methodological concerns which treat research as ‘openly ideological’ – i.e. as an intervention in the social order, rather than an explanation of it.

Author