Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Citing Vygotsky: Beyond the Zone of Proximal Development

Sun, April 15, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Vancouver Convention Centre, Floor: Third Level, West Room 303

Abstract

The objectives of this short introductory paper will be to present the aims of the symposium as a whole. The paper will also briefly describe the historical evolution of Vygotskian perspectives on pedagogy, with particular reference to language and drama. In doing so, it will report on a small-scale study – part of a larger project looking at the state of the fields in Anglophone countries – that analysed the patterns of citation in seven key academic and professional journals in the field of English Language Arts and Drama Education over the last five years. The journals were Research in the Teaching of English, Language Arts (US); English in Education, Literacy, Research in Drama Education (UK); English in Australia, Language and Literacy in the Middle Years (Australia). In addition to a quantitative analysis of citations of Vygotsky’s work, the citations in research articles identified in these journals were also analysed thematically for the lines of reasoning they were intended to substantiate. The most frequent citation across all seven journals was to Mind in Society (Vygotsky1978) and to the concept of the zone of proximal development. Very often, the ZPD concept was removed from its context in discussion of assessment and used to justify general social learning theories, even social constructivism, without any underlying theory of mind. In one case, the ZPD was rendered as the ‘pipeline of potential’ and used to substantiate arguments that it was ‘good to talk’. The paper concludes that the current state of appropriations of Vygotskian ideas in English Language Arts and Drama Education are often superficial and not well-informed. The paper argues, as does the symposium, that the great potential of a specifically Vygotskian contribution to pedagogical theory is a coherent theory of mind and of cultural development and it is in this direction that papers in this symposium follow.

Authors