Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
In the last decade, adolescent literacy has received significant attention, particularly boys’ lack of literacy engagement and their poorer performance on standardized testing. In the same time period, some very powerful research has identified adolescents’ out-of-school literate activities (e.g., Smith & Wilhelm, 2002; Hull & Schultz, 2003) and there has been a growing movement to incorporate out-of-school literacies with classroom practice.
Research on the use of classroom laptops has demonstrated the strong impact of computer use on writing development. Warschauer, Arada & Zheng (2010) report six areas of positive impact including providing tools for better writing through ease of drafting, revising, and publication; the strengthening of student sense of authorship and ownership; self-directed learning that developed students’ sense of autonomy; and a strong engagement with new media. Clearly, contemporary technology offers potential for more effective literacy teaching and learning. However, most of the research above has rarely focused on using new media to support adolescents who are struggling with reading, often those with less access to digital media in their homes.
This study uses a mixed methods approach to gain insight into responses of adolescents who are reading 3 – 5 grade levels below expectations to using the graphic organizer software programs Inspiration or Smart Ideas in a dynamic way to create non-fiction linear text. The learning environment was structured as one-to-one tutoring by teacher candidates, to be able to individualize and differentiate instruction and to take advantage of the students’ ‘literate identity capital’ (Rice, 2011). This study created spaces where students could deploy their literacy capital by writing about areas of personal interest, increasing authenticity, voice, and engagement (Sperling & Appleman, 2011). For the boys in the study, these areas of interest often included writing about their favourite video games, certainly a topic that was encouraged, following Cazden’s (2011) call to use students’ multi-modal interests as resources for learning.
Data sources for this study of adolescents in grades 7 – 10 include (i) pre/post reading assessments; (b) digital graphic organizers and pieces of writing created by the students; (c) online interviews with teacher candidates; and (d) learner profiles of the case study students, created by teacher candidates.
Results show the variability of initial response to the use of this digital tool, with some students resistant despite their own very weak handwriting while others, with more gaming background, were much more responsive. Regardless of initial response, these adolescents found the graphic organizer tools very engaging, particularly the visual aspects of colour, shape, importing of icons and images as well as the ease of making changes to the organizer. The small cells in the organizers focused and scaffolded student writing, promoting success and completion of what was for many the longest pieces of writing they had ever produced. Interestingly, even though the emphasis in this study was on writing, the reading assessments showed reading gains for most students.