Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Scaffolding Medical Students’ Self-Regulation During Practice on a Simulator: Divergences in Student/Expert Conceptions of Learning

Sat, April 14, 8:15 to 9:45am, Pan Pacific, Floor: Lobby Level, Oceanview 1&2

Abstract

Medicine is a profession that requires its constituents (i.e., trainees and practitioners) to self-regulate both their performance in daily practice, and their own learning activities (Frank et al., 2000; Duffy & Holmboe 2006; Regehr & Eva, 2006). In recent years, a confluence of factors including ethical and medico-legal concerns have caused the context of learning to shift from relying largely on clinical environments to incorporating additional contexts such as those using patient simulation (Brydges et al. 2010a). This shift has prompted an increased reliance on self-regulated learning (SRL) for sophisticated clinical skills by creating opportunities to learn them without the need for close supervision. This, in turn, raises possible dangers, such as the potential for developing bad habits, misunderstandings, and an overestimation of one’s preparedness for practice (Kruger & Dunning, 1999; Hodges et al., 2001). Yet, research that aims to understand and support the mechanisms of SRL in the simulation-based training context is relatively absent.

Using ‘Harvey’ (a patient simulator) to teach novice medical students the cardiovascular physical exam, we aimed to better understand naturalistic SRL in the simulation context and determine whether an intervention designed to support SRL (cf. Perry et al., 2004) might establish the value of ‘directed self-regulated learning’ (DSRL) (Brydges et al., 2010a; Brydges et al., 2010b). Specifically, we compared one group of students who engaged in ‘unguided’ SRL with a DSRL group that followed a structured learning plan developed by a clinical expert.

Our analysis emphasized two data sources: (1) performance-based data associated with students’ ability to identify seven cardiac murmurs (i.e., heart sounds) immediately after practice and on a 3-week delayed retention test; and (2) the sequence that students chose to learn the cardiac murmurs during the initial practice session and a second session that followed the retention test.

The SRL group required 33% less training time than the DSRL group, while achieving similar scores on both the immediate and delayed tests. Hence, using an expert-based approach to ‘direct’ the DSRL group appeared to have little positive impact and, in fact, slowed the learning process. The sequencing data provide some insight into this unexpected finding. Students in both groups showed a strong preference for sequencing their learning of the murmurs using a ‘location-based’ approach that grouped the murmurs by anatomical location. Despite following the expert-based plan that emphasized a ‘timing-based’ approach (i.e., phases of heart contractions) during the ‘directed’ learning session, most DSRL students reverted to the location-based approach during the second practice session. This suggests that the slower learning for the directed group may have been, in part, a function of the divergence between the conceptual framework that felt ‘natural’ to the students and the conceptual framework forced upon them by the expert’s design of the DSRL training module. These findings highlight how students’ previous knowledge and their interactions with the task shaped their learning in the simulation context. In the poster, we will explore this divergence between learner and expert conceptions of learning and discuss key implications for research and practice.

Authors