Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This paper reviews recent news reports about the current migration of African Americans to and from the American south to reflect on the political significance of constructing narratives about blacks, both inside and outside of the classroom. Drawing on recent work on the sociology and politics of emotion, the paper examines how the act of constructing narratives involves not just the assembly or recollection of fact, but also the development of a historical, socio-emotional argument that justifies some political identities and actions while delegitimizing others.
Over the last 30 years, the number of blacks living in the south has increased steadily, prompting a spate of media coverage about the meaning of African Americans’ presence in the region. Online versions of these reports often include multimedia elements, interactive data maps, and related news and opinion pieces, all of which are designed to deepen and broaden the reader’s understanding. This paper analyzes the narratives produced by online text, video/photo, audio, and graphic reports in major U.S. newspapers, to examine 1) what black migration narratives are currently being constructed by opinion leaders, 2) how those narratives categorize and characterize people and place, and 3) how the narrative constructions are related to the census data presented in the maps.
This analysis reveals that while interactive GIS maps accompany these articles focused on black population movement over the last 10 years, the text, video/photo, and audio news reports interpret African Americans’ contemporary decisions about where to live as rooted in and related to the civil rights struggle of the 1950s and 1960s. In particular, news reports present African American movement to the south both as black middle class “flight from” the disappointments of the northern racism, and as a “return to” familial, historical, and cultural roots. This “toward freedom” interpretation is in sharp contrast with the “Jim Crow Nostalgia” interpretation, a competing public narrative about black middle class movement that depicts that cohort’s move from urban space as the abandonment of poor blacks and a marker of racial inauthenticity.
These findings illustrate how and to what extent opinion leaders draw on the history of black migration to interpret and justify blacks’ contemporary choices. By highlighting the use of historical narrative in public conversation, this paper illuminates how the narrative construction skills developed in classroom settings play a role in shaping civic debate. The author concludes with a reflection on her own use of GIS census data maps in the design of a course assignment meant to problematize students’ construction of African American historical narratives.