Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Submission Type
Browse By Descriptors
Help
About Vancouver
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Purposes: This paper presents research in the context of a cross-institutional partnership between preservice secondary language arts teachers and sixth graders, along with the sixth grade teacher and university professor. Research questions were
(1) What did preservice teachers (PSTs) notice and comment upon in the sixth graders’ writing?
(2) What resources did PSTs draw upon to explain how they assessed and responded to the sixth graders’ writing?
(3) What, if anything, changed in the ways PSTs responded to and assessed student writing through the partnership?
Perspective/Background: Many preservice teacher education programs neglect writing altogether or address it in a manner that positions it as secondary to the teaching of literature (Smagorinsky & Whiting, 1995). Yet Grossman et al. (2000) have shown that beginning teachers do in fact draw heavily on experiences from their teacher education courses when teaching writing, particularly in their second year of teaching and thereafter. Thus it is necessary to find meaningful ways to incorporate experiences in responding to and assessing student writing into methods courses for teacher candidates.
Cross-institutional partnerships between preservice teachers and secondary students offer one avenue for such experiences. A growing number of reports have described the affordances of these in other content areas (Camicia & Dobson, 2010; Day, 2009; Eppley, Shannon, & Gilbert, 2011; Moore & Seeger, 2009); using them in writing teacher education capitalizes not only on the affordances examined in those projects but also on the opportunity to position teacher candidates and student writers as authentic audiences for one another’s work as learners.
Methods and Data: The context for the research was a semester-long partnership between a group of PSTs enrolled in a university English methods course and a group of sixth grade students. Prior to the exchange, the teacher candidates discussed samples of the students’ writing using a response protocol and a rubric; researchers collected written responses and an audiorecording of the discussion. Next, participants exchanged letters of introduction online, completed a writing assignment in tandem, met in person for a writing conference, discussed revisions online, and met again for a publication session; researchers collected all related documents as well as videorecordings of the face-to-face conferences. After the exchange, PSTs again examined and discussed samples of the students’ writing; researchers again collected documents and audiorecorded the discussion. Data were analyzed using inductive, open coding (Miles & Huberman, 1994) including within-case and cross-case displays.
Results: Preservice teachers began with deficit-oriented, reductive readings of student writing, focused on surface features and corrective in tone. As they worked with their sixth grade partners, their responses became more revision-focused and descriptive, with attention to how they might work with the students to resolve problems in the writing.
Significance: This research confirms the importance of early field experiences involving writing. Further, it suggests that such field experiences should include one-on-one, horizontal collaborations with students, which offer opportunities to experience student writing from the student’s perspective in a manner that foregrounds the student’s agency as a writer and potential for revision and improvement.